Both 860 and 1440's signals are mediocre, but I'd have to give 860 the overall edge here. Both stations have daytime signals that are pretty much equal to each other (1440 kHZ @ 5kW = 860 @ 1kW), but 860's nighttime signal can be heard from more than a block away from its towers. I don't even think the charm of 1440 (which is what this five-year-old, 100+ page thread is about) can save it from becoming a full-time brokered format.