• Get involved.
    We want your input!
    Apply for Membership and join the conversations about everything related to broadcasting.

    After we receive your registration, a moderator will review it. After your registration is approved, you will be permitted to post.
    If you use a disposable or false email address, your registration will be rejected.

    After your membership is approved, please take a minute to tell us a little bit about yourself.
    https://www.radiodiscussions.com/forums/introduce-yourself.1088/

    Thanks in advance and have fun!
    RadioDiscussions Administrators

Crutchfield Refusing to Publish My Review of the Receptor HD !

7

700WLW

Guest
I submitted my review over two weeks ago (they claim it takes one week to get a review published) and with three follow-up emails, they so far have refused to publish my review. Radio Shack, after two follow-up emails, finally published my review, after a month. Here is the copy of the email, I just sent to Crutchfield, again. Looks like both companies only publish mostly-positive reviews. BTW, Radio Shack has misspelled the Receptor HD, as Recepter HD, so searching for the radio on their website, returns nothing ! :D

Date: 10/5/06 12:41:15 PM Eastern Daylight Time
To: [email protected]
CC: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]

To Whom It May Concern:

I submitted the following review, for the Receptor HD Radio two weeks ago, along with a follow-up email, and my review has not been published; I noticed, that another review has just been posted. Would you please, reply to this request with an explanation, why my review was not published:

I tried this radio at an electronics dealer and could only get a few FM stations - the stations sounded exactly like analog AM/FM radio, but the analog AM/FM boom-boxes were able to get many stations. The Receptor HD had the supplied long-wire antenna attached, but is now being shipped with a 7-foot dipole antenna, which needs to be mounted high up and preferably outside; AM/FM analog radios just need the supplied internal ferrite-bar and whip antennas. In the case of HD Radio, the HD does not stand for high-definition, but hybrid-digital; HD Radio implements something called digital IBOC, which has only 60% the coverage of regular analog radio, poor signal penetration into structures, and causes adjacent-channel interference. When an HD receiver goes out of range of the digital IBOC signal, there may be a delay, as it switches back and forth to analog. HD Radio has extra HD channels, which evidentually, are just extra channels of low-bitrate streams of repetitive terrestrial radio. Save your money and get Satellite Radio, Wi-Fi Radio, or iRadio (iRadio will be appearing in Rokr E2 cellular phones), which have hundreds of stations; HD Radio just carries local stations. Wi-Max, or wide-area wireless access, will bring Internet Radio to portable devices, including automobile radios, by 2008. Sirius has just come out with the Stiletto, which receives Internet Radio via Wi-Fi hotspots, as Wi-Max will eventually allow for reception everywhere. Cingular and Sprint Wireless have 50 radio channels, available through their cellular phones, for a small fee. As a matter of fact, over 200 XM Satellite Radio and HD Radio stations are free on AOL Radio, so there is no need to buy expensive HD Radio receivers.

Thank you
 
Look at this load, I got in reply from Crutchfield:

Thanks for contacting Crutchfield. I researched the reason your review was not posted. This review was rejected because it did not fall within several of our guidelines, one of which is a requirement that the reviewer own the product being reviewed. The review in question states that you “tried” the radio at a local store, but trying it (particularly in a “store” environment, which typically is a radio frequency interference nightmare because of all the electronics in operation) does not meet our standard.

Thanks again. I hope this information helps.
Hannah
Customer Service
800-955-9091 ext 4092

But, the analog boom-boxes were booming away ! :D
 
Buy one, play with for 30 days and return it. You'll be customer then.
 
I got this abbreviated review submitted to CC - it will be interesting, if they post it in two days, as they indicated:

I tried this radio at an electronics dealer and could only get a few FM stations - the stations sounded exactly like analog AM/FM radio, but the analog AM/FM boom-boxes were able to get many stations. The Receptor HD had the supplied long-wire antenna attached, but is now being shipped with a 7-foot dipole antenna, which needs to be mounted high up and preferably outside; AM/FM analog radios just need the supplied internal ferrite-bar and whip antennas. In the case of HD Radio, the HD does not stand for high-definition, but hybrid-digital; HD Radio implements something called digital IBOC, which has only 60% the coverage of regular analog radio, poor signal penetration into structures, and causes adjacent-channel interference. When an HD receiver goes out of range of the digital IBOC signal, there may be a delay, as it switches back and forth to analog. HD Radio has extra HD channels, which evidentually, are just extra channels of low-bitrate streams of repetitive terrestrial radio. Save your money and get Satellite Radio, Wi-Fi Radio, or iRadio.

I put in my zip code too, and got this:

Gaithersburg - not carried
Rockville - not carried
Wheaton - not carried

:D
 
audiophile. said:
Buy one, play with for 30 days and return it. You'll be customer then.

YES - my review made it on Circuit City (actually, it got duplicated) ! Now, it is on Amazon, Radio Shack, and Circuit City - can't say, I am not doing my part ! :D

http://www.circuitcity.com/ssm/Cust...d/160671/rpem/ccd/productDetailReview.do#tabs

http://www.radioshack.com/product/i...uctId=2260757&support=support&tab=custRatings

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/cu...246884-8450553?ie=UTF8&n=172282&s=electronics
 
Status
This thread has been closed due to inactivity. You can create a new thread to discuss this topic.


Back
Top Bottom