Nate Wesley said:
If live and local shows were proven to be the lifeblood of loyal listenership, we'd never hear of any annual Holiday firings/layoffs from Cumulus and Clear Channel. Cat Country only gains in Pensacola by a 102.7 that directly ticks off listeners, and there's no way to know that WXBM will change enough to do that.
No way to know. I agree. I'm confident enough to bet a dollar on it though. I'll be explaining my observations of "hyper localism in the Pensacola metro" as I go on. The crew at Cat should be riding a high right now, but nothing has happened yet. Perhaps Cumulus will try to preserve localism, but in the name of cost savings and launching a new nationwide multimedia country format, Mobile has to be a more important city to Cumulus than Pensacola. Speculation, just going to have to wait and see on this one.
Nate Wesley said:
Or, they could do like a lot of smart auto dealers (and indirect radio station bankrollers) have done by casting nets to capture customers along the 'Gulf Coast' and not necessarily 'Daphne' (which is neither Pensacola or Mobile--more on that later). Are you betting on the convenient, coincidental Mobile/Pensacola 'divide' amongst WKSJ and WXBM (of which WYCT isn't an equal player) to be as reliable as the radio industry itself?
Ah, but here you are wrong. Many a business, including radio and TV stations, has tried to expand to cover "they whole Mobile-Pensacola TV market" by using those magic words "Gulf Coast". It doesn't work. It never has. Cumulus and CC salesmen don't even suggest that term, they recommend targeting one of the two cities on those 12 100kw sticks, or just listing all your locations in the coverage area.
Car dealers have a unique advantage, they have the ability to save Joe Six Pack thousands of dollars for making a 1 hour drive. Most people are willing to do that. Not all are. My mom, for example, doesn't care... she lives in Pensacola and by god she's only going to do business with a Pensacola car dealership... even after I've told her that car dealership is owned by a big corporation from Miami... she just doesn't care. Not typical, but also not an unusual action by Pensacola consumers.
There is an obvious divide between KSJ and WXBM today. Cat is trying to catch enough of the Pensacola market to keep going. Is cat a money machine? I doubt it. Nationalizing Cat's only real competition into in an age where portable/digital/satellite music programming is easily obtained, the timing for such an endeavor by Cumulus could very well be perfect. Assuming NASH plays out in a way similar to what I envision, KSJ will have a little bit of competition in Mobile and Cat will be the sole local Pensacola Country outlet. How will NASH do in Pensacola-Mobile? I have no idea.
Nate Wesley said:
You can't use your own observational biases and apply them to everyone like that...you know better.
In this case I'm using my "own observational biases" as a simple way to describe what I've seen in this community for 20 years. 25 years ago I wasn't of the mindset to notice these things. I'm not applying this to everyone, YOU know better than to assume that. I'm applying this bias to a significant amount of the Pensacola metro population. Significant? Define that as close to 50%.
Nate Wesley said:
People make the Mobile-Baldwin-Pensacola jaunt to work, shop and play just as people make the opposite Pensacola-Baldwin-Mobile jaunt. Nowhere is this better observed when you have promotable events and concerts that are neither in Pensacola or Mobile (Gulf Shores, Orange Beach, pretty much all of lower Baldwin County, AL). There won't be any Northwest Floridians traveling west for Mobile-area Mardi Gras? The Senior Bowl? Alabama's Deep Sea Fishing Rodeo? The select events that choose the Mobile Civic Center over the Pensacola Bay Center? Gas has never been that expensive.
Plenty of people live in Pensacola and work in Mobile. Mobile has lots of good, high paying, jobs. Those people take their money and buy hoses in Baldwin County, on Dauphin Island, and in Pensacola. I have no knowledge whatsoever of the this working in the opposite direction. I've never encountered anyone living in Mobile with a single full time job in Pensacola. When I moved to Fairhope back in 2004 I was the only person in the neighborhood that didn't work in Mobile. Why did I move to Fairhope? The property was a better investment than anything available in NW Florida. All these biases don't necessarily apply to me. Why don't I live in Fairhope today? Hurricane Katrina took my house and I didn't have any insurance.
Nate Wesley said:
I can figure all sorts of [loaded] reasons why fewer people live in the Mobile area, but this notion that most extend that to avoiding Mobile at all is just silly.
I can tell you that when folks from out of the area accept those nice jobs in Mobile that they come to Pensacola looking for their first home in the area. I deal with the real estate industry every day (realtors and relocation companies). I deal with people moving from (say Denver) to Pensacola with a new job already arranged in Mobile. I have to assume that the recruiters at those Mobile businesses are suggesting their new employees look to Pensacola for a place to live. There's no other way it makes sense for people who can't even pronounce the word "Mobile" to be purchasing a new home in Pace. It has been explained to me by 2 or 3 families that they are living here for educational reasons. There are multiple public schools in the Pensacola/Pace/Gulf Breeze area that can provide an education equivalent (on paper) to that of an expensive private school in Mobile or Baldwin county. One time I slipped and told a Doctor that he had overpaid about $125k for his new house in Gulf Breeze. His response was, "I know, but I saved the $400k it would have cost to send my sons to private school." Another factor that might play in for families relocating to Mobile, they can get a house in Florida and get in state college tuition for their children at a Florida college. Outside of Dixie, ignorant people really turn up their noses at Auburn and UofA.
Everyone from Pensacola travels to Mobile for Mardi Gras once or twice. No one makes a tradition out of it. In fact, I'd say the percentage of Mobilians in the crowd at the Pensacola Grand Mardi Gras parade on the Saturday before Fat Tuesday is higher than the percentage of Floridians at any Fat Tuesday parade in Mobile. Pensacola Mardi Gras is far more family oriented than Mobile... and Mobile Mardi Gras is no New Orleans Mardi Gras. Traveling to events in South Baldwin county... doesn't phase us. On the other hand, I don't know anyone who's attended The Gulf State Fair, Bayfest... heck, we wouldn't even drive over to Mobile in the 1990's to see all the UFC cage fights at the Civic Center, we just waited for the VHS tape to be released. The Senior Bowl usually profiles at least one player from Pensacola, so yea, people go to that, but before we got Pro Baseball in Pensacola, no one traveled to see the Bay Bears.
I kinda rushed through this long post. But I stand behind my observations. Pensacola folks avoid Mobile. Heck, Milton folks avoid Pensacola. I have an unstaffed office in Midway because I would loose customers if they knew I was answering the phones at my Pensacola office. There is a strong sense of hyper localism here. People want to keep their business as close to home as possible, and even though Mobile is a sub-one hour drive.... they don't want to go there.
These same principals have always applied to those 12 100kw FM radio stations. That's why it has always been necessary for Pensacola and Mobile to have their own Country, AC, and Top-40 radio stations even if they broadcasts from the same dang tower. It's obvious when you watch WEAR TV news, they avoid reporting anything west of Mobile bay like the plague. You have seen this all your life Nate. Open your eyes. If you can't twist what I'm typing into something that makes sense to you, something's wrong.
As for NASH FM. It's coming. What will it do? As our buddy Tibbs pointed out, who the hell knows? If it works, what's next?