luperm said:
I'd chalk that up to part of the grieving process. Whenever someone loses a format they like, they have to come up with justification for why the format failed. For example: the signal wasn't good, it was the "bean counter's" fault, the suits don't understand the format, the station had too much debt, the sales guys did not know how to sell the format, advertisers area biased, corporate has an agenda, it's the haters' fault, the station was a success but it was just mismanaged.....etc, etc, etc.
Sometimes things just don't work, or are not a good fit for the marketplace, or are bad radio formats.
Luperm,
From our perspective, we're giving facts to why things have happened. No one is mourning here, we don't have a place for a wake or burial, lol. Whatever happened had happened and we're just looking into all aspects.
Okay, let's get on the format then since we didn't cover that angle as much. The majority of you criticize dance music as being too niche. In the case of Hot 107.1, IMHO, they were being too niche on a specific genre
within dance (EDM). Granted, EDM is very popular right now. Could aspects of it interspersed with other dance music elements (club, house, vocals, recurrents) work out in terms of a format? I believe so, and yes that depends on the market. Could EDM in itself sustain its own? I will admit for now...
NO.
That's why when you see me post about the format, I call it "dance/EDM". Not just EDM. You need the diversity in dance music for a format like this to work out. That's why Joel Salkowitz had been successful with Hot 103/97 and Pulse 87. You couldn't just run one specific element of dance music. Looking at it from a New York perspective, there's still a house crowd here, those that are into the vocal aspect of our dance brand, and those that still love the classic freestyle and never let it go, and yes, the pop/CHR element because there are those that think of dance music as just that so, yeah you add that along with everything else. That would make it a potential success....not just branding it to one specific element within.
And yeah, that's where I don't think corporate really understands it. Yes, radio is a business and at the end of the day, all they want are numbers and revenue. I got that. I've
BEEN got that

. I'm not going to diss Brian DeGrasse, the PD of Hot 107.1. I've met him at the Promo Only Summer Sessions this past year and he's a good guy. He gave it a try and unfortunately it didn't work out.
A lot of us may be doing this "armchair quarterbacking" but it's just because we care about our music and perhaps we're just trying to think of different angles to go here so that when the next station launches somewhere, that it can be a success.
Thank you for your time.