I think certain markets can definately handle 2 or more urban and or rhythmic Hip Hop Hits stations... In Detroit they have 98 JLB Hot 102.7 and even the CHR in Disguise Channel 95.5 is really a hip hop station for white boys. At one time Detroit had I think 5 Urban stations.
Miami has 99.1 WEDR, 103.5 WMIB, and for rhythmic Hip Hop for latinos, whites and some blacks, you got Power 96
I think new Orleans could support 2 or 3 Urbans, and-or one Rhtyhmic hits and Hip Hop station.
Saint Louis could definately survive with a 3rd hip hop station... they have 100.3 KATZ which has the big signal,,, but radio ones Hot 104.1 doesnt have the best signal, so I think Saint Louis could definately support a 3rd urban or Rhythmic Hits and Hip Hop type station. Atlanta has two urbans, and one Rhythmic that pretends to be an Urban but is too conservative and too weak of a signal,, and both their Mainstrream CHRs in A-town are too Hot AC conservative.. I think 95.5 The Beat should be a youth friendly Hot sounding Mainstream CHR,, keep the Hip Hop Lean, but play some POP, Dance, and Rock too,,,, It isnt aggressive enough to be a real Hip Hop station, and its too Urban to really be a Rhythmic hits or CHR...
Here in Indianapolis we definately need a second Urban station, and possibly a 3rd Hits and Hip Hop Rhythmic station,,,, Radio Ones Hot 96 plays too many Ballads during the day, and they air Russ Par in mornings, I want a local Urban Morning Show that knows Indy and is funny, but not over the top stupid like some morning jocks. We have so many underperforming and duplicate formats in Indy, I dont know why no one has tried to go urban yet, or even a Rhythmic hits and Hip Hop format with both black and white jocks..... I will admit that R-O Hot 96 does have some killer Mixshows and some DJs with some good Skills,,, and it would be hard to top that in this market. Mixshows are very important on any kind of Urban Format,,, but not so much on,,,lets say a CHR......