• Get involved.
    We want your input!
    Apply for Membership and join the conversations about everything related to broadcasting.

    After we receive your registration, a moderator will review it. After your registration is approved, you will be permitted to post.
    If you use a disposable or false email address, your registration will be rejected.

    After your membership is approved, please take a minute to tell us a little bit about yourself.
    https://www.radiodiscussions.com/forums/introduce-yourself.1088/

    Thanks in advance and have fun!
    RadioDiscussions Administrators

Erica Grow leaving Ch 6 at end of year

I'm not that surprised, she has been on mostly weekends, and seems to have trouble reading the teleprompter, often. It is strange timing given Dave Roberts retirement.
 
Wil said:
I'm not that surprised, she has been on mostly weekends, and seems to have trouble reading the teleprompter, often. It is strange timing given Dave Roberts retirement.

Meteorologists only read off a prompter when it's to do a tease. That's all.
 
I'm surprised. I know this was her dream job growing up in the area, so I doubt she wanted to leave. However with Dave Roberts leaving you wouldn't expect 6abc to let her go at this time either.
 
WCAUTVNBC10 said:
Wil said:
I'm not that surprised, she has been on mostly weekends, and seems to have trouble reading the teleprompter, often. It is strange timing given Dave Roberts retirement.

Meteorologists only read off a prompter when it's to do a tease. That's all.

UHHH, That is not accurate. The ENTIRE weather is scripted WORD for WORD. The ENTIRE news cast is scripted WORD for WORD. Only during a segment transition is there room for an injected word or two, but that is ENTIRELY scripted too. Welcome to the news. ... Although it is sad, she simply cannot read or seem naturally spoken from a teleprompter. Welcome to the news. This has been transcription. I'm your announcer Symphony Sid along with Wally Cannan the weather man.
 
Sam Lit said:
WCAUTVNBC10 said:
Wil said:
I'm not that surprised, she has been on mostly weekends, and seems to have trouble reading the teleprompter, often. It is strange timing given Dave Roberts retirement.

Meteorologists only read off a prompter when it's to do a tease. That's all.

UHHH, That is not accurate. The ENTIRE weather is scripted WORD for WORD. The ENTIRE news cast is scripted WORD for WORD. Only during a segment transition is there room for an injected word or two, but that is ENTIRELY scripted too. Welcome to the news. ... Although it is sad, she simply cannot read or seem naturally spoken from a teleprompter. Welcome to the news. This has been transcription. I'm your announcer Symphony Sid along with Wally Cannan the weather man.

I hate to break the news to ya but TV meteorologists. Having done the job myself (albeit not at a very high level, college and a couple of small markets) and I've never read off a prompter to give a forecast. I had to write my teases and hand them in to the prompter and that was it. I produced the forecast graphics. Before the show began I got a copy of the newscast script/rundown and that was it. You're on your own with delivering your forecast.
 
WCAUTVNBC10 said:
Sam Lit said:
WCAUTVNBC10 said:
Wil said:
I'm not that surprised, she has been on mostly weekends, and seems to have trouble reading the teleprompter, often. It is strange timing given Dave Roberts retirement.

Meteorologists only read off a prompter when it's to do a tease. That's all.

UHHH, That is not accurate. The ENTIRE weather is scripted WORD for WORD. The ENTIRE news cast is scripted WORD for WORD. Only during a segment transition is there room for an injected word or two, but that is ENTIRELY scripted too. Welcome to the news. ... Although it is sad, she simply cannot read or seem naturally spoken from a teleprompter. Welcome to the news. This has been transcription. I'm your announcer Symphony Sid along with Wally Cannan the weather man.

I hate to break the news to ya but TV meteorologists. Having done the job myself (albeit not at a very high level, college and a couple of small markets) and I've never read off a prompter to give a forecast. I had to write my teases and hand them in to the prompter and that was it. I produced the forecast graphics. Before the show began I got a copy of the newscast script/rundown and that was it. You're on your own with delivering your forecast.

Suffice to say there is a major difference between small skeleton staff markets and major news operations like Philadelphia.
 
I wasn't trying to knock her with my previous post, I was just sharing an observation. I think it's great when someone from the area gets a shot at staying in or near the market they grew up in to work. I watched her again this morning, and you can tell when she gets to the end of a line and then starts a new line. She is a bit off, as if she starts a new sentence with each line on the prompter, even if the next line is a continuation of the prior sentence. It is as if she is trying too hard. I hope she finds success in her next endeavor.
 
Sam Lit said:
WCAUTVNBC10 said:
Meteorologists only read off a prompter when it's to do a tease. That's all.

UHHH, That is not accurate. The ENTIRE weather is scripted WORD for WORD. The ENTIRE news cast is scripted WORD for WORD. Only during a segment transition is there room for an injected word or two, but that isENTIRELY scripted too...

It takes a tough man to make a tender forecast... Keep f---in' that chicken...
 
Sam Lit said:
WCAUTVNBC10 said:
Sam Lit said:
WCAUTVNBC10 said:
Wil said:
I'm not that surprised, she has been on mostly weekends, and seems to have trouble reading the teleprompter, often. It is strange timing given Dave Roberts retirement.

Meteorologists only read off a prompter when it's to do a tease. That's all.

UHHH, That is not accurate. The ENTIRE weather is scripted WORD for WORD. The ENTIRE news cast is scripted WORD for WORD. Only during a segment transition is there room for an injected word or two, but that is ENTIRELY scripted too. Welcome to the news. ... Although it is sad, she simply cannot read or seem naturally spoken from a teleprompter. Welcome to the news. This has been transcription. I'm your announcer Symphony Sid along with Wally Cannan the weather man.

I hate to break the news to ya but TV meteorologists. Having done the job myself (albeit not at a very high level, college and a couple of small markets) and I've never read off a prompter to give a forecast. I had to write my teases and hand them in to the prompter and that was it. I produced the forecast graphics. Before the show began I got a copy of the newscast script/rundown and that was it. You're on your own with delivering your forecast.

Suffice to say there is a major difference between small skeleton staff markets and major news operations like Philadelphia.

Uhhhhh, Sam, you're wrong on this. So far off, yet so cocky about it, that it's laughable. :D

I worked as a weathercaster/met at a pretty decent sized station and can assure you that the weather is ad libbed - except, perhaps, the teases. Although where I worked, we ad libbed those too. However, I know whether a tease is on the teleprompter or not depends on the station.

What does not depend on the station is the fact that weather IS NOT scripted. Your "script" consists of the weather maps and forecast text that you (or a producer) set up beforehand.

Best to leave weather to the pros.....
 
brnout, and wcau are right. The weather isn't scripted. if it was, they would have a hard time pointing & looking at the maps while trying to read. If you notice unlike a newsreader, they're not looking directly into the camera then entire time when doing their report. Also, on a Saturday morning, even in a major market like Philadelphia, they have a skeleton staff.

As for Erica Grow and her trouble reading, this is also not true. She indeed stumbled when talking, but that was when it was ad-libbed. When reading off the teleprompter, which she did for her green reports, ask erica grow, and image of the week she had no problems. Infact after reading this the first time I made sure to pay attention to her final green report, and they were short on time. She ran thru it quickly with no problems. So as it turns out, she probably would've been a better weather presenter if it was scripted word for word.

BTW, while we now know she left on her own. If we didn't know yet, I would also say maybe her reporting was a factor. She was a terrible reporter.
 
Sorry to bump this, but I just remember a proving point that the weather isn't scripted. If you ever passed the old Dave Robert's garden spot on cityline, they had 3 monitors. One was of that very camera shot, so they could see themselves and adjust their hair or whatever. The other was action news on no delay via closed-circuit, and the 3rd was the graphic board which had the stats that they would read. There was no word for word teleprompter out there.
 
I worked at an NBC station for 3 years in a top 40 market, and the weather was NOT scripted. Here is what generally happens:

The weathercaster or weather producer create the weather presentation "slide" sequence with graphics, such as the surface map, followed by the regional temperature map, followed by the 7 day forecast, etc. The weathercaster then gives a copy of that graphic sequence (called a rundown) to the producer and director, so they know what will be next. The producer gives the weathercaster time cues in his or her earpice during the ppresentation, such as "1 minute, 30, wrap, etc."

The whole weather sequence is basically adlibbed around each graphic "slide." That is why weathercasters have a "clicker" because it allows them to advance the slides on their own. If the clicker breaks (as it often does), the director can move the presentation along. (This is why they have a copy of the rundown.)

So in short, the presentation is scripted as far as the order of each graphic but not word for word as far as what will be discussed. As long as they stick to their time cues, are knowledgeable in their field, and let their crew know what's next, weathercasters can pretty much wing it!
 
Rob departed Fox 29 two years ago to go to koat Albuquerque which is an ABC owned station.Rob Guarino just left his job at KOAT and moved back to Philadelphia last week maybe he will be going to Channel 6
 
tommygraser said:
Rob departed Fox 29 two years ago to go to koat Albuquerque which is an ABC owned station.Rob Guarino just left his job at KOAT and moved back to Philadelphia last week maybe he will be going to Channel 6

Gaurino will not be going to 6. It's channel 6 policy not to hire 3, 10, and 29's throwaways.
 
I just found out Rob Guarino will not be going to Channel 6.he has to wait until April due to contractual issues with his previous station...he moved back to Philadelphia last week because he has a new job at Trellist, Inc. in Wilmington DE and will start in January..He does run his own weather website at http://www.liveweatherblogs.com/
 
digidan said:
Gaurino will not be going to 6. It's channel 6 policy not to hire 3, 10, and 29's throwaways.
I don't understand that at all.
 
digidan said:
tommygraser said:
Rob departed Fox 29 two years ago to go to koat Albuquerque which is an ABC owned station.Rob Guarino just left his job at KOAT and moved back to Philadelphia last week maybe he will be going to Channel 6

Gaurino will not be going to 6. It's channel 6 policy not to hire 3, 10, and 29's throwaways.

Channel 6 would be smart to hire Rob. I don't understand Fox replacing him with Bolaris?

Hey John, we gonna get more snow?
 
Status
This thread has been closed due to inactivity. You can create a new thread to discuss this topic.


Back
Top Bottom