• Get involved.
    We want your input!
    Apply for Membership and join the conversations about everything related to broadcasting.

    After we receive your registration, a moderator will review it. After your registration is approved, you will be permitted to post.
    If you use a disposable or false email address, your registration will be rejected.

    After your membership is approved, please take a minute to tell us a little bit about yourself.
    https://www.radiodiscussions.com/forums/introduce-yourself.1088/

    Thanks in advance and have fun!
    RadioDiscussions Administrators

Free Music, No Commercials... How's It Viable??

I seem to remember TuneIn discontinued the recording service because of copyright issues in Europe.

That sounds familiar, although I'd expect it was a problem here too. The music industry wants people to BUY music from them, not record it off the radio. The DMCA is filled with language that was designed to prevent people from recording audio from digital streams. The whole inspiration was to prevent people from getting "CD quality audio from the radio."
 
We have a great oldies HD station in Philly (WMGK HD-2) operated by Beasley which does not stream and there are no commercials. I similarly wonder how they make money or even break even with expenses such as music royalty payments.
 
Yes, speaking of HD subchannels playing music without commercials... why do they? I recently disovered a good commercial-free classic rock HD subchannel. So now it's mostly what I listen to when driving around. How is that good for commercial stations which are already struggling to attract and retain listeners?
 
We have a great oldies HD station in Philly (WMGK HD-2) operated by Beasley which does not stream and there are no commercials. I similarly wonder how they make money or even break even with expenses such as music royalty payments.
Asheville NC has an oldies HD station with a translator. At first the only commercials I heard were classic commercials that would have aired when the songs were popular, but I have heard a few actual commercials in more recent years.

It used to be better in my opinion, playing even Johnny Mathis and Nat King Cole, but there seemed to be more louder 70s music this year when I listened. Still not as bad as Good Time Oldies which ventures into the 80s and can be quite loud.
 
Except for that one episode of WKRP In Cincinnati where it was a controlled powdery substance instead ...

This happened when I was working in a vintage record shop. I found in the new stock a near mint A&M promo of Amy Grant's Unguarded LP, originally sent to a local radio station. There were three large jewelry bags of said controlled powdery substance that that neatly fell out of the sleeve. Flattened to fit neatly in the sleeve.
 
Some iHeart channels are commercial-free. They include Classic American Top 40 (Casey Kasem years, not sure of the Ryan Seacrest years) and I think the iHeart Cafe is also commercial free. Some weekends the Yacht Rock channel is commercial free.

As said above, I don't know how iHeart makes any money from these channels, other than the commercial we sometimes must watch when first starting the channel.
 
I see 50 commercial free IHeart music channels. Some have hosts. I also wonder why they are providing them.
Are they perhaps in response to satellite radio?
 
I’m not a fan of how TuneIn operates lately. In addition to the pre-roll ads, they now interrupt live streaming stations to play their own ads. It’s incredibly annoying. There used to be a way to just pay them for no ads and I used to do this. It also let me record stations. However, now they require you to subscribe to their other premium services which I have no desire to do and they no longer offer the recording option. At least I don’t believe so.
How do you expect them to pay royalty fees like from Sound Exchange if they don't sell commercials or charge a subscription? Just eat the expense?
Doesn't sound like a very good business model to me.
Also, a long time ago, I created an online station and ran it for about 6 months. I did it just for fun, as a friend had given me a ton of high quality Shoutcast streams for dirt cheap. Because of that, I just covered the rest of the costs. If I had planned for this to be more than long term, I would’ve done things quite a bit differently.
You mean like charge a subscription fee or sell ads?
 


Back
Top Bottom