RTibbs said:
Beau, Steak and AJ with Mayhem in the AM on 680 was a good show. That was before Steak's hat size increased 5 sizes.
I believe you have hit the nail on the oversized head. That was a good mix of sports info (Beau), entertainment (AJ) with Steak running the point. But, to further the sports analogy, once Steak started trying to score more, he became a lousy point guy.
This is one thread I feel qualified to comment on, since I am not in the biz, but a listener only. Since I am major sports fan, and spend way too much time driving, I have been listening to ATL sports radio since 750 had Munson and Van Note doing a PM drive sports show. When they started up the first 680, I was all over it.
For my personal taste, I like the shows to be caller driven, but not contrived like, "Call in and tell us your best tailgate recipes..."
Putrid! I like them to focus on local, but mix in some national perspective. Most importantly, I like the shows to strike a balance between information and entertainment. I hate 3 hours of discussing "David Wright's OPS" or Ty Cobb's place in history... it leaves my eyes glazed. Don't try to impress me with your drinking prowess, or your frequency of strip-club visits. And I couldn't care less about the hip music you listen to or the trendy dinner you eat. Simply talk sports like you might at the lunch table or around the water cooler. Pretty simple, huh?
Currently, The Buck and Kincade Show probably comes as close to fitting the bill as any of them.