Look, I'm not sure if you're going to read my response to this or not but I thought it's worth it, regardless, so here it goes:
I support the idea of a major TV station focusing on New Jersey issues and happenings. However, we must keep in mind the following:
- The way in which Channel 9 became a "New Jersey" station was questionable. It was a way for the then-owner of the station to avoid having their broadcast license yanked by the federal government. It did not work out for them in the long run, as they had to sell their interest in the station to another group.
- Channel 9 has historically been one of the lowest performers in terms of ratings. The picture quality of the programming showed the effects of lack of investment in the station, from when RKO owned the station.
- I wouldn't qualify shows like Morton Downey Jr's as "great". He was a loudmouth and controversial, for sure, but not someone who I found entertaining. Joe Franklin I can see because he's a local legend. I liked Lloyd Lyndsay Young but he's a weatherman on a low-rated TV news program. The weather can only be that much interesting. Funny that no mention was made of the Howard Stern Show, which did attract an audience, nor of Richard Bey.
- I put "New Jersey" in quotes because that area just across the Hudson is only important for certain businesses in terms of locating operations as close to the big city without having to pay New York cost-of-living expenses. In other words, New Jersey is there simply to be used when convenient. They didn't build an international airport in Newark just because they thought that city was worthy of one. The Giants and Jets still use "New York" as part of their name. I won't even comment on the Red Bulls soccer team. Then there are the various communication operations based in the area, including WXTV, WNJU, Channel 13 and Channel 68. Has anyone ever looked at whether either of them has done enough New Jersey-focused programs as much as with respect to Channel 9?
Now if someone could bring forth a viable business plan to operate the TV station and bring in viewers while being a primarily New Jersey-focused station, then great. Maybe the Fox Stations Group would happily sell to such group. However, I doubt that would happen anytime soon. Notice that Channels 2, 4, 5, 7, 11, 31, 41, 47 and 68 are owned by either the networks or other major entertainment groups. Channels 13, 21, 25, 50 and 58 are non-profit, public broadcasting channels. The rest are either low-power, religious or ethnic stations. As Channel 9 is a full-power station, chances are that if it were on sale tomorrow than it would fetch a pretty penny, even for a station with a spotty history. My 9 does carry Yankee baseball. It used to carry Mets baseball. Sports programming isn't cheap and more games are on cable than before. The New Jersey Devils are exclusively on cable. Not even hockey can be enticed to go on OTA channels. The Nets have practically disappeared from the "free" airwaves and the owner still is trying to move them to Brooklyn. Guess what? It costs a pretty penny to put sports on that channel. Who will be willing to pay for it if not some owner with deep pockets? Don't say the team because the only reason why a team would pay for put their games on is if they won't get exposure, otherwise. Even the Red Bulls are on MSG! Arena football? Women's soccer? Skateboarding? All on cable or about to disappear in the case of arena football.
Who can buy Channel 9 and do what New Jersey residents say they should do? There were many opportunities to do it before Fox bought the station. Why didn't it happen?
I cannot predict the future but I will say this: I wouldn't be surprised if Channel 9 does slip back into the city sometime in the future. There might be a deal in which they're allowed to do so in exchange for New Jersey getting a full-powered VHF station from somewhere else. I read the other day that a station group wants to bring in a VHF station from Nevada, of all places, and has petitioned the FCC for authorization. Look to that very closely as it might help decide the fate of Channel 9.