I think you've missed my point. If you digitize a vinyl recording, you get all the original artifacts - tape hiss and all. Nothing added or subtracted (from the standpoint of the human ear.)Except you've removed the original master tape from the equation, eliminating tape hiss and greatly enhancing dynamic range. Yes, you have the limitations of the vinyl and the means of playback, but you had that AND the limitations of tape previously.
Here's a fascinating history: https://www.aes.org/aeshc/pdf/fine_dawn-of-digital.pdf
I'm NOT comparing a vinyl record made from a master tape vs. a CD made from the same master tape.
1) Plug a turntable into a computer.
2) Record the vinyl album.
3) Burn a CD of the recording.
4) See if you can tell the difference.
