If the latest numbers are to be taken with a grain of salt, any data we get during this crisis unfortunately has little or no merit. This tells me that advertisers will(or have already) frozen their budget because:
a)They are closed or barely doing business
Depending on the advertiser and size of market, this may or may not be true. Larger chain restaurants in larger markets in areas with higher population density may have their dining rooms shut down, but may be doing takeout and delivery. Smaller market restaurants in more rural markets may not have that option. The chain will want to advertise to let the public know they can still get their Bloomin' Onion.
b)Radio listening has decreased so sharply that advertising now is likely a waste of money.
It's more like; if you can't open your doors, why pay for advertising when you need that money for rent?
c) There is no clear way to find out who's listening and who's not.
I don't think the ratings methodology has changed. Just the number of participants and listening habits during stay-at-home orders.
Radio advertising is going to be re-evaluated as an effective way to reach people before things turn around. That could take months or even years.
Advertising for radio, and for all forms of media, started being re-evaluated back in 2008. That's the reason why station valuations were completely turned on their collective heads. This Pandemic is only creating a new unique environment, where the mobile listening suddenly went away, and yet, people are spending time consuming many forms of media. The challenge for media here is; advertising was removed, or greatly diminished from the equation.
If I was a business owner and wanted to let the public know that my business was now open, I would go to another form of media.
Then I argue, you wouldn't be a very smart business owner. If one were open for business, and had the dollars to advertise on radio or TV, there's a much more captive audience spending longer periods listening/watching, with fire sale's on advertising right now.
When we finally see the industry moving back in the right direction, when would we take ANY numbers seriously? Why even subscribe to Nielsen?
Depends on whether the station or group is under a contract, and whatever discounts baked into that contract therein. I'm sure there are negotiations to suspend Nielsen to cut costs, but that's on a case-by-case basis.
I'm struggling to find something positive in all of this.
You're not the only one! I guess the positive may be that businesses are being forced to be creative like never before to survive. In the end, the creative ones will live through this unanticipated world event, while the others will just fade into history.