No PD of any station is going to get on the phone with "a listener" and say "Yeah, the station is struggling". They will always talk of rainbows and unicorns no matter the reality.
- The CHR battle....Yeah, there really isn't one. WABD is crushing in every sense. HMN can barely hit a 2 share in Pcola, and is almost entirely invisible in Mobile in the ratings. At this point, rebranding & tweaking is off the table. 107.3, as a CHR, has done that too much in the 2-3 years in the current format. The CC small mkt CHR game plan didn't work, this time. If you want that signal to have impact, you gotta flip it. As is, HMN is a "value added" station. Not a whole lot of worth by itself, but thrown in a deal to get money on the books for KSJ, TK, or Lite Mix, it what it's good for. Maybe that's why CC hasn't pulled the plug, yet.
Or maybe, it's because the question of "what do we do with it?" is tough. Can't go sports for reasons that have been discussed 1000x over before. It CAN'T go ESPN because WBSR has that contract (and is showing some decent numbers in some dayparts), there's no viable play-by-play rights available. WNSP carries So. Alabama Jags football, basketball, and baseball. You could make a try for that, but then you run into the problem of nobody in Mobile really caring enough. Ever see the attendance for a Jags Basketball game? Baseball draws pretty okay, and the football program is growing. But not enough listenership to make a play for those rights.
Alt rock? Can't cannibalize TK from the top with Rocket and low with ALT.. Especially with how the rock product and TK is struggling, lately.
Any form of Country? Markets are saturated.
About the only thing that might appear viable is urban. You could grab a couple shares from BLX, turn that 1-2 share signal into a 3 share station, and maybe grab a few more dollars than what you get with HMN. The only problem I could see is, how do you pair/sell and urban with the other brands in your stable?
WCOA-FM serves a purpose. It clears nat'l Cumulus Media shows and commercials. That means $ for corporate with tiny overhead. You don't want to move Magic to 100.7. Leave it where it is. It's serving the city well, and still scoring well! Even with DLT and the monster signal. Pcola listens to Magic when in the city. They listen to DLT when they're everywhere else.