• Get involved.
    We want your input!
    Apply for Membership and join the conversations about everything related to broadcasting.

    After we receive your registration, a moderator will review it. After your registration is approved, you will be permitted to post.
    If you use a disposable or false email address, your registration will be rejected.

    After your membership is approved, please take a minute to tell us a little bit about yourself.
    https://www.radiodiscussions.com/forums/introduce-yourself.1088/

    Thanks in advance and have fun!
    RadioDiscussions Administrators

So I just got rid of my HD Radio...

I have one in my car but have no HD2 content worth listening to.
The audio is great and I know of several places where I would be happy to use it.
Sadly, where I live was one of them, but not now.
I am patient; it will stay in the dashboard and I will go through the dial every now and then.
 
ai4i said:
I have one in my car but have no HD2 content worth listening to.

Yes, this has been my experience in most markets I've traveled to. Very, very little compelling content on the HD2 or 3 side for the most part. In the larger markets, there may be one marginally interesting HD2 and that's usually it. Otherwise they seem to be limited to low appeal extensions of the main format, simulcasts of sister AM signals, or very highly targeted programming (South Asian anyone?).

One market where I've found some exceptions to this was Salt Lake City, where there were a couple of really great music formats on HD2, including a 50s-60s gold station, a classic alternative station (which was awesome) and a couple of other good ones. In my travels, that's been the only bright spot.

For all of there supposed support of the IBOC system, the big corporate owners seem to only use HD2 as a "platform" for whatever they're trying to market. CBS' move with Last.fm is a fine example. Fact is, who cares? Not one new HD radio will be sold to hear a format that's basically another CHR - this one pushing a corporate marketing concept. That's such obvious corporate kiss-butt thinking that it makes me laugh.

Better would be to offer programming on HD2 that you can't get anywhere else. How about urban/AC in Boston? Real oldies in most markets? Actual dance music? There is a lot that could be done to sell HD Radio on the basis of content. In other words, you're missing something by not having it. Ibiquity and their partners have failed miserably in doing this. Even when you take the plunge and buy an HD Radio, it's quite a ho-hum experience for the most part. Now it's probably too late for them to make a marketing splash. Amazes me how much money some people are paid to be absolutely incompetent.

As for HD on AM? Shut it off and save a few trees. It's useless.
 
Here in LA we have BBC in Spanish, 50-60's oldies, a second classical music service, and standards on HD in addition to the usual secondary rock and Spanish language channels.

The other thing that I noticed is that I was listening to one of the FM channels and I noticed the sound got worse suddenly. When I looked the HD had dropped out and we went back to FM. That is the first time I have noticed a distinct quality difference.
 
In New York City, if Pulse 87 were to go off the air this week, and another station flipped their HD2 to pure dance and aggressively marketed it, they would get a sizable percent of Pulse 87's cume to buy an HD radio. Running a dance format on an HD2 would also require little programming, since I am sure there is an Internet dance station that will love to provide programming for the HD2.
 
Nick said:
In New York City, if Pulse 87 were to go off the air this week, and another station flipped their HD2 to pure dance and aggressively marketed it, they would get a sizable percent of Pulse 87's cume to buy an HD radio. Running a dance format on an HD2 would also require little programming, since I am sure there is an Internet dance station that will love to provide programming for the HD2.

I noticed in today's Inside Radio that CBS plans to program a F/T dance format in San Francisco - reportedly with jocks - on 99.7 HD-2. Yes, that's exactly the kind of thing that they need to do in order to try and sell HD radios. Personally, I still tend to be pessimistic about the future of this platform as far as market penetration goes. However, at least someone is using their head when it comes to programming. For once.

We'll see if they end up using an analog translator in order to get actual listenership.
 
Nick said:
In New York City, if Pulse 87 were to go off the air this week, and another station flipped their HD2 to pure dance and aggressively marketed it, they would get a sizable percent of Pulse 87's cume to buy an HD radio. Running a dance format on an HD2 would also require little programming, since I am sure there is an Internet dance station that will love to provide programming for the HD2.

My taxi driver had 87.7 running in the background this morning, and it was pretty solid from LGA to downtown Manhattan. I didn't hear any dropouts driving around Times Square. Wonder if an HD2 would do as well? Or whether people would bother replacing their otherwise perfectly usable auto radios to get HD?
 
K6JHU said:
Here in LA we have BBC in Spanish, 50-60's oldies, a second classical music service, and standards on HD in addition to the usual secondary rock and Spanish language channels.

The other thing that I noticed is that I was listening to one of the FM channels and I noticed the sound got worse suddenly. When I looked the HD had dropped out and we went back to FM. That is the first time I have noticed a distinct quality difference.

That is station to station, when I was still firing up my Sony (almost literally) I picked up an FM station about 10 miles away that sounded worse in HD. A 100KW NPR station from Boston sounds great in IBOC but it also sounds great on analog FM, the numerous negatives with IBOC are not worth the (sometimes and debatable) small increase in sound quality.
 
Status
This thread has been closed due to inactivity. You can create a new thread to discuss this topic.


Back
Top Bottom