azumanga said:
But nevertheless, it doesn't mean that they could insult listeners who tune into the station from a faraway place. If they suspected a prank, they should've used decorum and written a nice letter back, saying that it was not possible, or at least asking for more information -- chastising them could've been bad for the station in the long run, as the Missouri listener may have avoided the station like the plague if he visited Denver (and encouraged others to do the same).
As I said, sometimes it depends on just who at the station reads the letter. And even if they are somewhat savvy about DXers, the more extraordinary the logging, the more proof one needs.
This story was told to me by an old DXer. Over the years, I never heard of any active TV and FM DXers on Bermuda, though it would seem to be a dream location: no lo-band locals, no stations at all (save for the few locals) within 700-800 miles, clear water path to the East Coast, those big stagnant "Bermuda highs" that produce tropo up and down the Atlantic seaboard, single-hop skip range to pretty much everything east of the Mississippi, etc.
Anyway, the story goes that back in the 1960's, a non-DXing fellow on Bermuda happened to notice some signals coming in on the normally "blank" channels on his TV. One of them turned out to be WPIX-11 in New York -- about an 800-mile over-water tropo catch. He decided on a whim to call the station long-distance to tell them. (And this is back when international long-distance was expensive!) Well, even though they had received domestic DX reports and were aware that sometimes their signal could be seen quite far away, this was just a bit much to swallow.
So, the chap in Bermuda, anxious to avoid being branded as a hoaxer, gave WPIX his phone number, and invited them to call him back. Maybe as more of a lark than anything else, they did phone him back, going through the International Operator (no direct-dial overseas in those days). He then held his phone up to the TV, and to their amazement, the Doubting Thomases at WPIX heard their own live audio being echoed back at them on the line! Apologies ensued. <g>