OH MY GOD, FOR THE LOVE OF CHRIST, PLEASE STOP!!!
Radioradio, and Northstar you are embarrassing yourselves, and what's most sad about it, is that you are completely oblivious to it. The only thing worse than obnoxious gloating, is obnoxious gloating when you have ABSOLUTELY NO reason to be!!!! This debate is not open to interpretation, it's not even a matter of opinion... YOU ARE WRONG... As a point of fact, you are wrong. And more importantly it shows that you know next to nothing about this business. Reading your posts reminds me of having a conversation about radio with my Barber, or my neighbor. I'm not trying to be insulting, I mean this literally. I've had this assinine conversation with my neighbor: "Well, all of my friends listen to so and so, so they must be doing really well"! Really? REALLY?! I don't besmirch my neighbor, he doesn't work in radio, but he doesn't hop on radio message boards and make a complete ass out of himself, either!
Oh and by the way, Doug, Don't fall for the "where are your good ideas" nonsense. It's a crude 13 year old's style of argument. Gee, If I lose based on my original point, I'll just change the basic structure of what I was complaining about, and then hit 'em hard as to why they "can't answer my simple question". This would work, if at anytime Doug claimed (in half as an obnoxious tone as you) to have the answers, but he never did. He just explained why, like em or hate em, the DH would not work on Movin'. Believe me, you wouldn't be doing The DH any favors. Buzz means nothing if you can't back it up with well suited programming. Using your argument, the niche programming of ALL radio stations today doesn't mean anything. I guess the DH would be a great fit for a news talker, or maybe an all news format, or wait, wait, how about all spanish, or soft hits, as long as they have buzz. I know these sound ridiculous, but you already said they'd be a great fit for a female oriented dance format! I would've rathered use that as my assinine example, but you beat me to it while being completely serious!!!!!!!!!
Look don't get your panties in a bunch, nobody was saying that JV and Elvis aren't good. I personally haven't ever heard their show, and have no opinion either way to cloud my judgement. It is just a fact, to be good in a particular format, many times you alienate yourself from other demographics. It's especially true for FM Talk. Just because you've heard a significant number of female callers on their show, means absolutely nothing when it comes to how they impact that demographic. Radio station callers have never been a good representation of their listeners. And quite frankly, you should know that! I could go on the air tomorrow, and discuss any of the hack topics that seasoned broadcasters know to steer clear of (Gun control, abortion, pot, etc.) and have a full board of callers for as many hours as I choose, but that would mean ABSOLUTELY NOTHING when it comes down to who's listening.
Now I fully expect to be completely discredited in the usual message board fashion:
1. "It's pretty easy to attack other's while being anonymous"- I never attacked anyone. Just trying to help stop the madness.
2. "You don't have very many posts, so you must be one of the others pretending to be someone else"- No, I was just inspired to write by you. Be flattered.
3. Then finally I'll be challenged the same way Doug was, with the "if you're so great, why don't you tell us, in all of your infinte wisdom, what you would do HA, HA, HA, HA"- My answer is simple, I would search to find someone who appeals to women, and has a track record of appealing to women. It may not be a satisfactory answer to you, but it is light years ahead of your idea of hiring someone who has no quantifiable appeal to women, other than your buddies who listen.
Thank you.