Sorry for the rant. If you're still reading this, I'm sorry for wasting your time.
In case you haven't noticed, this board is
all about rants, screeds and speculatin'. If it weren't for those components, along with Unrequited Love For The Lake and half a dozen other issues, there'd be no "Radio Discussions" ... oh, and no pop-up ads with pictures of large breasted women and questionable-apps for converting pdf files. You made some very good observations. So rant on!
And it goes something like this...
Upon further review, WBUF, in its present format, might be the ideal situation to accommodate the Bills ... or Sabres .. or both. Stop laughing. OK, so the board consensus is the present WBUF morning show is vapid and the music is neither fish nor fowl. The morning show has been given more than enough time. It's getting bug-splattered by Shredd & Ragan on one end, and WGR on the other. So it would have to be blown up and a local show put in its place.
Putting local talent together would take a major investment. Shred and Ragan, and the WGR sports talk morning show cannot be flanked, they have to be targeted, and that would take a
lot of talent,
and a PD whose time is dedicated to nurturing and guiding the talent each day. So right off the bat, money has to be invested in talent, and more money has to be invested in a PD that has vision,
protect-the-license-programing-skills and coaching skills. Those attributes don't come cheaply(ly), and they most often don't belong to even the best students who just graduated from Buffalo State, Syracuse or Fredonia.
Here's a suggestion: Slick Tom Tiberi as an anchor with Rich Gaenzler. Now you need a woman who can stand up to the guys and straighten their ties. Add a good, experienced PD who knows the game and can guide, encourage and when necessary, crack the whip on the talent. Yeah, the ad for that person would be: "
Wanted, staff psychologist, attorney, coach, warden and father confessor."
Middays? Keep the present music format for four books. Find out if a full blown sports talk morning show can light a fire under middays. This is a daypart that can be used to flank the WGR, 97 and 103. Carefully. Big A earlier pointed to an approach that caught his interest. If a midday music/sports weave presentation can't get traction, blow it up and go
local sports talk. Forget the flanking tactic. Forget shows like Rome and The Herd. Been there, heard that. Gotta be local and broadside.
Two young turks could be scheduled in middays, and as long as they don't sound like mindless frat boys after chugging a six of Genny Pounders, they might pull some numbers. Better combo, a turk and a legacy, each complementing the traits of the other. But there's an issue with young guys doing sports talk. They
need a PD who can guide them and dedicate time to
nurturing them, and the talent has to
listen to the coaching and get it done. In a way, it's like cultivating a QB or receiver fresh out of college coming into the NFL. So many young guys come out of college and think they're going to be the next Jerry Rice or Tom Brady ... in radio/TV, the next ESPN morning anchor. Another thing about young sports guys on the air, the guys who
listen often think
they should be on the air in place of the guys who have the gig ... because "those guys on the radio don't know shizzle about sports." Testosterone wars.
PM drive has to be live with at least two veterans who know the Bills and Sabres, know sports and know the community ... and yeah, can talk fantasy football (in moderation) and their kid's ability to play Purple Haze after a year's guitar lessons. Knock WGR's Shopp and Bulldog all we want (and we often do here), but they're now legacies in the sports talk arena. Legacies. The brand. Listeners may bytch about them, but they know them and listen to them. S&B can be knocked off, but it will take time, money, promotion, skill and a few contracts with players or ex-players to appear on the show. And as is usually the case with players and ex-players, they'll need coaching because most jocks think all they have to do is show up... which is why most jocks wash out. They have to be
in the radio game, not there just to collect a check and ride their (fading) on-field rep.
Nights? Tough task. This is where talk radio wins when the chips are on the table, and gets blown away when there's nothing there. It's a daypart susceptible to intense listener abandonment on one side of the scale, and intense listener loyalty on the other ... the true sports believers. There are so many competing alternatives: on-line, TV, on the field, on the ice. World championship poker, X-Box. Participation in sports. Women. Life. Kids. Nights is a precarious daypart that doesn't generate a lot of cume (unless it's the Sabres or Bills), but can contribute modest to moderate quarter hours. So bring on the young turks. Ladies and gentlemen. This is where they develop their chops. This also is where the PD needs to be
very attentive. If the turks are good and work out, they become your daytime bench players. If they don't, they go back to Home Depot or grad school. Nothing wrong with either.
All nights? Replays. Special daytime replay-promo features and maybe ... weave it with music ... and lots of cross promos. Did I mention promos? Lots of long form cross promotion for the daytime features.
And now the disclaimer ... the preceding screed is just a run up the flag pole. Tear it up. Take it apart. Have at it. It's what this board is all about. Game on!