It's been a few months since anyone has commented on this thread. Press Communications has had plenty of months to promote this station and hammer it into the public consciousness, and they have. Advertising is everywhere: buses, billboards, malls, and everywhere else you can think of. You know - what they DIDN'T do with G-Rock back in the day. I actually knew a lot of people that wanted to know what happened to the station in Ocean County, which tells you how badly they botched spreading the word about the frequency change from 98.5 to 106.5. But I digress
Back to Fun 107.1. Anyway, the station has been highly promoted in the entire market. The ratings they're getting, in spite of all this, are absolutely pathetic: http://ratings.****************/cgi-bin/rol.exe/arb516
Why is the station struggling in spite of all the money spent in promoting it and having a signal that can be heard anywhere and everywhere in the market? It could be because pretty much their entire staff sounds like they belong on a college radio station instead of a strong commercial FM. But most likely, it has to do with the fact that you can hear everything they play on half of the other stations on the dial, including sister station B 98.5 (which, it bears mentioning, is easily topping it in the ratings despite having a very limited presence in the northern half of the market). The differences between B 98.5 & Fun 107.1 are only apparent after you've listened to them for a substantial period of time: the former leans slightly more toward urban and rhythmic titles, while the latter plays some sleepy soft rock artists (i.e. Colbie Caillat, Phillip Phillips). Take that away, and you're left with two safe-as-milk Top 40 stations whose Top Ten titles are almost all the same and receive as many as 70+ spins on both stations.
While this doesn't show up in their branding, Fun 107.1 is supposed to be an "adult" station. This is how it reports, and it does play a number of decidedly soft rock acts. But it has one of the most juvenile morning shows I have ever heard. In addition, you can also hear plenty of the most youth-oriented Disney pop songs out there: this includes One Direction, Ariana Grande, Taylor Swift, Meghan Trainor, and one song that was so childish and sugary that you would expect to hear it on repeat at Chuck E. Cheese (I looked it up - it was Demi Lovato & Cher Lloyd).
It's disappointing to see what has become of Press, which just six years ago ran two of the most interesting commercial FMs in the state with G-Rock and The Breeze. In their places are two stations doing pretty much the same thing, and that's playing a format with extremely limited adult appeal and plenty of shallow, synthetic fluff. They would be smart to take Fun 107.1 all Christmas at this point and launch a new format after that, preferably something that has some appeal to people over the age of 25.
1.) I don't know the financial situation between when G-Rock was on the air and now. If the company had a reason for promoting G-Rock less, that's their business decision.
2.) The airstaff IS disappointing. But that's only part of the problem. The other part is that when someone tunes into 107.1 or 99.7 anymore, they don't know what they're going to get. There was a stretch where the station went from Gold-Based AC to Mainstream AC to Gold-Based AC to Mainstream AC to Modern AC to Hot AC to Recurrent/Current Leaning Hot AC with higher spin totals. All while under the Breeze name, the 107.1FM name and now the Fun 107.1 name. Add in some lackluster imaging (while keeping the same voice guy all the way through), and you've pushed off people who tuned in for the Gold-Based lean, while haven't pulled in new listeners to the Hot AC format.
3.) In reality, who cares if B98.5 and Fun 107.1 share some of their playlists? Press having a CHR and Hot AC in the same building is no different than iHeartMedia having a CHR and Hot AC in Philly (Q102 and Mix 106), or having an AC, a Hot AC, and a CHR in LA (KOST, KIIS, and My), or even Greater Media having a Classic Rock, a Mainstream rock, and a sports station in Philly (WMMR, WMGK, The Fanatic). Having the two stations together and using them as a selling point is smart. "Want to reach woman in Monmouth/Ocean? Have we got the stations for you."
4.) One Direction, Ariana Grande, Taylor Swift, Meghan Trainor, etc. have all charted on Hot AC. They're playing the hits their target demographic states they want to hear.
5.) Just because you don't like the music doesn't mean everyone else hates it too. You're obviously not the demographic they're targeting, so no, you won't like it. I'm not the demographic that Power 99 in Philadelphia is targeting, but that doesn't mean I'm going to complain that I think they should. I go listen to something else.
All of that aside, do I think Press could/should do something different with their stations? Maybe. Giving B98.5 a full market signal would be an OK idea, but with competition from Z, AMP, PLJ, Fresh, The Point, etc. from the north end, I don't know if the added Monmouth signal would help them at all. As much as you pine for the days of G-Rock, honestly, taking 107.1 and 99.7 and running a Radio 104.5-esque format could do a little better ratings wise, but DavidEduardo points out... Radio 104.5 doesn't bill insanely well, and it's sister station, Mix 106, while getting lower ratings, routinely outbills them.
So is Press better off with Fun 107.1? We don't know unless we see ALL the numbers.