I think the issue is more of "if you ask the current group of 35-54 listeners what station plays all their favorite older songs" you will get the response of it being WHTT.
If you ask the people who were 35-54 in the 80's the same question, it's unlikely that they will name WHTT as the station's window has "remained on the same street" but the passersby have changed. In fact, if they know about Radio Buddy, they will likely name that station instead.
The audience aging out of target demos makes "heritage" of vastly less importance today, where most stations have about 80% of their listening in a roughly two decade (or one generation) age span.
That's hilarious. Anybody who was in their 50s in the 1980s is now pushing 90(or not). It's quite the "undertaking" to ask them about listening habits from Yesteryear.
Mr. Moderator, is the "Not Buddy" guy who speaks for Buddy violating your terms of service? Just lift his ban. That way he can tell us how his station really is #1 if Nielsen didn't cheat him. All those feeble 80 somethings who forgot or misplaced their diaries...