• Get involved.
    We want your input!
    Apply for Membership and join the conversations about everything related to broadcasting.

    After we receive your registration, a moderator will review it. After your registration is approved, you will be permitted to post.
    If you use a disposable or false email address, your registration will be rejected.

    After your membership is approved, please take a minute to tell us a little bit about yourself.
    https://www.radiodiscussions.com/forums/introduce-yourself.1088/

    Thanks in advance and have fun!
    RadioDiscussions Administrators

Steve Harvey to Host Primetime ABC Court Show

Ugh. There for a while it seemed there were at least a half dozen or more court or judge shows. Not sure there's a need for even more. Also, while I think Steve Harvey is great and when I worked with him about a dozen years ago he was good to the staff and crew (hopefully that's not changed now that he's become more popular and famous), but he already has plenty of exposure, I'm not sure we need more Steve Harvey. Just like Ryan Seacrest, it can be a bit much once you start hearing and seeing the same guy all the time on many shows and on many forms of media.
 
Props to Harvey's agent. They should get more than the standard 15%, considering how many different gigs Harvey gets. I'd thought that beauty pageant hosting SNAFU would have blown his career into the guardrail, but no, it seems like he got even more high profile work.
 
Props to Harvey's agent. They should get more than the standard 15%, considering how many different gigs Harvey gets. I'd thought that beauty pageant hosting SNAFU would have blown his career into the guardrail, but no, it seems like he got even more high profile work.
I can't stand the man, but it appears he did as good a job as anyone could recovering from that. And so he got to come back the next year, and they even had fun with it on another pageant.

A prime time judge? Really? We have enough judges during the day.
 
I can't stand him either but I like the celebrity version, if I know the celebrities.

I read one description of the new show that says he will be dealing with "family feuds".
 
In reading a few articles about this show, it seems Harvey will be bringing on roommates or dorm buddies or family members who are having a dispute or squabble, and in a comedic environment he'll hear all about the problem and render a decision. One article also says he may also judge some small claims as well, but obviously he's not an attorney or a justice, so I don't see any of his decisions being legally binding, it's just entertainment.

As an aside, when I was working for a local government years ago, there were a few times when some petty issue or neighbor dispute made the local news and producers from Judge Judy contacted the parties involved and asked for them to sign wavers and come on her show to have their cases heard...So her program had people scanning news articles looking for fodder for her program, Harvey will probably do something similar. On his Instagram feed, he posted a notice saying they were "casting" for it:
 

Attachments

  • Harvey.jpg
    Harvey.jpg
    86.1 KB · Views: 2
Last edited:
Court shows in primetime? Networks have ran out of ideas and are bringing daytime junk to nighttime...
What's next: Steve Wilkos Tonight?
 
Hyperbole. It’s a show. I have no interest. But it’s one program that puts a twist on the genre. It’s hardly a signal of the end of days.
 
The problem with this in my mind (and this isn't a criticism of Steve Harvey) is it diminishes the role of a judge. At least with Wapner and Judy, we had two people who had been actual judges at one time. Not so with Steve. So it's saying that anyone can be a judge, and that's not true. Although with some judges today, they ignore the law and just hand out more opinion. That's what this is. Unless Judge Steve will consult with an actual judge at some point. But hey, they've got to fill prime time with something, and this is cheaper than a scripted drama or comedy. If Flip Wilson can play a judge, so can Steve.
 
So it's saying that anyone can be a judge, and that's not true.
In all but 4 or 5 states, Judge is an elected position. I have as many legal qualifications as Steve Harvey (possibly fewer!), but I could run to be county circuit court judge this fall. All I would need is a couple hundred ballot petition signatures, and then win an election in November.
 
In all but 4 or 5 states, Judge is an elected position. I have as many legal qualifications as Steve Harvey (possibly fewer!), but I could run to be county circuit court judge this fall. All I would need is a couple hundred ballot petition signatures, and then win an election in November.

So maybe that's what this demonstrates: The complete folly of American jurisprudence. We've already seen it with TV talent shows. The music stars we once fawned over are no better than that kid bagging groceries or waiting tables. They don't need actual talent, they don't need education, just build a fan base on social media, and you're in.
 

Here comes the judge: Steve Harvey an initial hit​

His show's premiere was the most-watched non-football program on ABC last week, its audience of 5.2 million people nearly two million more than a season-opening episode of the much better known “The Bachelor,” the Nielsen company said.

Just before the debut, the Daily Beast's Kyndall Cunningham predicted “Judge Steve Harvey” would leave viewers laughing and in awe of the host's branding capabilities.

“Despite the innate absurdity of the project — mainly in that Harvey is not a judge nor has any legal experience — his entry into the ecosystem of network court shows is an undeniably astute move,” Cunningham wrote.
 
I can't stand the man, but it appears he did as good a job as anyone could recovering from that. And so he got to come back the next year, and they even had fun with it on another pageant.

A prime time judge? Really? We have enough judges during the day.
He may not be for everyone, but when hosting a "Family Feud" episode, and learned that one family was from Welch, West Virginia (his hometown, I believe), and that they worked with a nonprofit helping folks in that area, he stopped and had a check cut for $5,000.00 to benefit said nonprofit-it was allegedly his own money. Sure, he could have found this out in pre-interviews, and had the check cut privately, but perhaps he was trying to drum up support for a part of America that needs so much help, through no fault of their own.
 
I caught about a minute of one episode and it was mindbendingly awful. But people also enjoy the Bachelor and Dancing with the Stars. So be it.

As for him not being a real judge—that ship sailed so long ago it may be coming back around again. That a couple of the old timers were once actual judges is all well and good, but no one is watching for real legal education or insight.
 
Status
This thread has been closed due to inactivity. You can create a new thread to discuss this topic.


Back
Top Bottom