I'll just give my personal story. My home town, near Celina, Ohio, was very early on FM. WMER, Celina, Ohio, signed on in 1960. It was 740 watts ERP, located on top of the Celina Music Store, with an antenna beside the store. The owners of the music store sold to Lee Rutherford and Ron Rumley and flipped to Hit Parade '68 (67, 70 and maybe 71). Before that it was a hodgepodge of beautiful music, top 40 and Big Band. My Junior High principal did a weekend shift when I was in 7th grade. The same family owns the Music Store, which is in the same location as 1960, and still outfitting high school bands and rock bands. The radio station, although with several ownership changes, is still on top of the music store as WKKI. Strong AM stations would have been WOWO, WLW, WJR and CKLW, which was where the teens went, especially starting in 1967.
Celina's first AM, a 4-tower daytimer on 1350 (WCSM) came on the air in 1963. 2 years later, an FM joined the AM which was simulcast. FMs that came in included WPTH and WKJG from Fort Wayne, WHIO-FM, Dayton (previous all beautiful music and WIMA, Lima.
Getting to popular tastes---WDAO, Dayton, was one of the first Urban FMs in the country. It got people in the habit of listening to contemporary music on FM, earlier than a lot of markets. This likely helped WONE-FM to flip to top 40 in 1969. It later became WTUE. I don't know the year but in the early 70s, The University of Dayton's WVUD would pick up an AOR format. All the jocks were students, but there was professional management as a commercial station. Several broadcasters went on to bigger things.
The first time I heard the AOR format was when WRIF, Detroit drifted in. Detroit wasn't local to me but it would come in with almost any tropo. I could catch WDRQ aping CKLW's format without the Can-con.
In Fort Wayne, WPTH flipped to top 40 as Rock 95, WPTH, using TM Stereo Rock. I also listened to WLBC-FM, Muncie IN with Drake-Chenault "Solid Gold". In 1979, top 40 WMEE flipped from 1380 AM to 97.3 FM. A year later, WPTH went live under Mark Elliot. 1979 was a big year for top 40 AMs flipping to Fm.