Sort of correct. A lot depends on the altitude of the actively reflective layer of the atmosphere at the time. Most long-distance reception on AM comes from multiple skips.
So, if you are trying to get WABC from New York in Quincy, Illinois it is likely that the skip will occur over Ohio, maybe 500 to 600 miles away. Darkness occurs on hour intervals in each of the 24 time zones, so the Quincy reception might start being possible about an hour before Quincy sunset and an hour after New York sunset.
This is why the FCC has some stations reduce power in "Critical Hours" to protect from what DXers call "sunset skip".
Critical hours for radio stations is the time from sunrise to two hours after sunrise, and from two hours before sunset until sunset, local time. During this time, certain American radio stations may be operating with reduced power as a result of Section 73.187 of the Federal Communications Commission's rules.
So, in CA you might hear skip at 7 PM if Summer sunset was 9 PM or at 3 PM if winter sunset was at 5 PM.
In your case of Honolulu reception, the issue is not darkness in Hawaii, but of darkness between Carmel and Honolulu somewhere out over the Pacific.