• Get involved.
    We want your input!
    Apply for Membership and join the conversations about everything related to broadcasting.

    After we receive your registration, a moderator will review it. After your registration is approved, you will be permitted to post.
    If you use a disposable or false email address, your registration will be rejected.

    After your membership is approved, please take a minute to tell us a little bit about yourself.
    https://www.radiodiscussions.com/forums/introduce-yourself.1088/

    Thanks in advance and have fun!
    RadioDiscussions Administrators

"Newsroom culture clash" at CBS News

The retired longtime news director of KCCI-TV in Des Moines, Dave Busiek, writes a commemoration of CBS News that might as well be a eulogy.


Some context: KCCI is a powerhouse among CBS affiliates and still produces a strong news product. It’s the station I watch for local news whenever I’m in Des Moines. One of Busiek’s predecessors, and the original news director for the station, was Russ Van Dyke, a man known as “the Walter Cronkite of Iowa”.
 
I remember watching Sharyn Alfonsi in her first TV job, weekend anchor at KHBS/KHOG, when I was in college. Even then, she was obviously a big fish in a small pond who was going to go on to do great things. I remember seeing her on 60 Minutes about 20 years later and being shocked but not surprised.

Fun fact: Her weekend co-anchor was Christy Musumeci (then known on-air as Christy Carlo), who went on to MSNBC and co-hosting mornings with Imus on WFAN 660.

Both Alfonsi and Carlo/Musumeci left KHBS/KHOG for Hampton Roads, where they competed against each other for a few years, one at WAVY, the other at WVEC.
I remember Cecilia Vega one of the now removed 60 Minutes correspondents when her first TV appearance was reporting for KGO-TV San Francisco after her time reporting for the San Francisco Chronicle. Some of her biggest stories in the Bay Area was when she covered the time Gavin Newsom was then mayor of San Francisco and Kamala Harris was then District Attorney for San Francisco. Back then we thought Vega would be a Bay Area TV legend as anchor but that was disproven once she went on to ABC News and later CBS News on 60 minutes to cover the biggest stories in the nation.


Vega had already done well by then. With her mother’s prodding, she did go away, to American University in Washington D.C. to study journalism, then to a fellowship to the non-profit journalism school at the Poynter Institute. She rose through reporting gigs at the San Bernardino Sun, the Santa Rosa Press Democrat and found her way to the San Francisco Chronicle.

Once a common track for so many journalists, it was in daily newspapers that Vega first made a name for herself. As a City Hall reporter for the Chronicle, she tussled with then-mayor Gavin Newsom, who was battling both personal scandals and budget deficits (“God, you used to give me so much shit,” Vega recalled Newsom, now the governor of California, telling her recently during an interview for a forthcoming 60 Minutes story). But she could see the newspaper business changing—and with it her job. Meanwhile, she’d done spots for KGO-7, the local ABC affiliate. The station liked what they saw in her and made overtures for her to come on board. Each time she said no. She was not that kind of reporter.
 
FYI This week's 60 Minutes was a repeat of stories originally aired last year.

Relatively safe stories: An interview with Germany's defense minister, and a story about declining birth rates.

It wouldn't surprise me if they continue with repeats until the fall.
 
It wouldn't surprise me if they continue with repeats until the fall.
They said about 2 weeks ago they have concluded their season of new stories and will be showing repeats over the summer. That is nothing new for 60 Minutes.

I do wonder if they will show repeats of stories done by the correspondents that are no longer with the show.
 
Hope best of luck to Scott Pelley in the same way Sharyn Alfonsi, Cecilia Vega and Tanya Simon left CBS News. And here’s more, but then again the only person that can stop Bari Weiss are the Ellisons. The Ellisons are the ones that put Bari Weiss there and decided that she is more powerful than even CBS News President Tom Cibrowski.


 

Pelley went off.
“She is murdering ‘60 Minutes,’” the correspondent said. “She does not love this place. She was brought in to kill it, and she’s been doing exactly that.”

Mr. Pelley added: “She has no qualifications for her job; you have slender qualifications for this job. The changes that she’s made at the ‘Evening News’ have been catastrophic, so why should we expect that any of this is going to be any better?”
Mr. Bilton responded: “Well, I will show you. That’s what I have to say. That is my plan over the next two weeks. I’ll be meeting with everyone. I’m very excited to meet with everyone, yourself included.”
 
And kudos to him for that.

"Mr. Pelley pressed Mr. Bilton repeatedly on why CBS had fired Ms. Alfonsi and Ms. Vega. Mr. Bilton said those decisions predated his hiring. Mr. Pelley asked Mr. Bilton why he had accepted a position at a program “knowing that you will never be welcome here.”

“I have no problem taking a job in a place that I am not welcome in,” Mr. Bilton said. “I don’t think that will be the case.” He added: “You are not going to intimidate me in front of this group of people. I want that to be clear.”



Really?

Mr. Bilton moved to conclude the meeting after roughly 15 minutes. He encouraged the assembled staff members to partake in the food that had been laid out.

“I just want to thank everyone for graciously being so welcoming,” Mr. Bilton said. “I look forward to talking to you in a one-on-one setting as these meetings are scheduled. And enjoy the bagels.”

The “60 Minutes” staff applauded Mr. Pelley after Mr. Bilton departed.


Oh, to be a fly on the wall in those one-on-one meetings...
 
Does anyone still watch that?

60 Minutes, AFV and The Simpsons -- all Sunday Night shows that seem to go on forever...

And as far as 60 Minutes "reruns" for the summer, that has usually been the norm. The only things that might be different are post-segment "addendums" or "Since we first aired that segment,..." updates.
 


Here's more but this time Dan Rather, Lowell Bergman and others written a letter to Paramount CEO David Ellison to hold him accountable for the stuff happening at CBS News with Bari Weiss and the staff.

Dan Rather, Lowell Bergman and dozens of other journalists urged David Ellison to protect CBS News’ editorial independence on Monday, noting his legal duty to do so after Skydance acquired Paramount and “60 Minutes.”

“We, the undersigned, urge you and your management team at CBS News to uphold the principle of editorial independence that has made ‘60 Minutes’ — in the words of the show’s new executive producer — ‘the most important television journalism brand this country has ever produced,’” they wrote in a letter to the CEO. “Acquiring CBS News came with a legal requirement to serve the public interest, avoid political interference and maintain editorial independence.”


“Modernizing the show for new audiences and new delivery approaches is important — but not at the cost of editorial integrity. The wholesale dismissal of editorial management, without a public pledge to maintain the values, standards and traditions of this program, puts the legacy of ‘60 Minutes’ in jeopardy,” they continued. “What is at stake is not just the future of the most important and enduring television journalism program in this country, but the future of free and independent press in America.”
 


I hadn't seen anybody post this yet so I thought I'd go ahead and do it. All those cries from real journalists--they're falling on deaf ears! Unfortunately, I highly doubt what they have in mind will work to bring in younger viewers--it will only turn the older ones away.
 
All those cries from real journalists--they're falling on deaf ears! Unfortunately, I highly doubt what they have in mind will work to bring in younger viewers--it will only turn the older ones away.

I agree. The complaints were all baked into the decision. They knew this was going to be the reaction. They've already gone through it with Colbert, so they're sort of numb to it now.

But you talk about the age of the audience, so I looked at last Sunday's ratings. Yes, it was a repeat, so it was not a regular show. But it was up against the NBA on NBC. Thunder vs. Spurs. 60 minutes had 6 million viewers, the NBA had 8.2 million. But when you look at 18-49 share, it was 4 share for 60 Minutes and a 27 share for the NBA. That means 1/4 of all TV viewers were on NBC. It might have been higher if it was the NY Knicks.

Granted I don't think there's anything they can do to 60 Minutes that will make it competitive with the NBA. Even Joe Rogan. The audience is what it is. ABC already tried to bring down the audience age for a show like 20/20, and they get a 2 share at 10 PM. Friday night was also an NBA night, and as usual, the Spurs game had a 24 share. As I said, I think all of this is baked into the decision. Long term, it's likely the show will be going away in a couple of years. But then, so are linear TV networks and the rest of CBS.
 
I hadn't seen anybody post this yet so I thought I'd go ahead and do it.

FOX News has Hannity. Ellison needs a big name to put up against him in his quest to turn CBS into the next rightwing mouthpiece.

Joe Rogan would certainly fit that role but he wouldn't be cheap. David and Daddy Ellison have unlimited money, though, so Joe Rogan could end up being the big winner while the American people lose again.
 


Back
Top Bottom