Has C&W or Country *ever* done well on the very long Long Island?
I recall in the WJRZ days of Countrypolitan 97 -- the 60's -- that WFYI 1520 Mineola gave the format a try. But they were a bland version, no pizazz, and got blown into the ocean by WKBW even before sunset sometimes.
1580 Patchogue (as WSUF? or WDRR?) gave it a spin in the 70's. They were another daytimer at the time, though.
And 94.3 'Smithtown' tried it for a while. A gal I kept company with, a former Led Zeppelin fanatic, said she hated the phony laughter on morning shows and found the music okay.
A better gauge of Country's appeal on Long Island would be, of course, some huge FM signal trying it out, like WWYZ in CT and WXTU Philly. Scant chance of that happening, though.
The music itself bears some blame. Now, I'm an old city goat who grew up with Ernest Tubb, Don Gibson, Loretta Lynn, Red Sovine, Sherill-Sutton, etc. And the newer stuff has certainly gone through its stages, what with the Outlaw days, the more-Los Angles-less-Nashville sonics, the MTV treatment, the same homogenization and just-add-some-likker to a formula that pop music has too long settled for product from three music companies. I can't tell the diffence at times between if I have on an A/C, Country or Contemporary Christian station playing in the car. And when some boom-boom-clap of sampled Rap gets tossed into the kickapoo punch, I'm gone.
It's probably not a matter of a market of some 2,500,000 'deserving' its own Country station. No more than NYC's 16,000,000 people accepted one. Barring a blockbuster movie or TV show I'm too reminded of years ago when stations played the Italian hours on weekends, and today out here when stations do the same for Polka and Irish shows -- and think that Country on Long Island is headed that same way.