There's another thread on this board about WMGM being picked up in Pottsville, measured by Tom at 126 miles. No question, a long haul. I would consider the HAAT, and more importantly, height Avboce Sea Level. Pulling up "t-102" info, they hav a 128ft tower, but are mountain located with a HAAT of over 500', and Height Above Sea Level of over 1900'.
That's one tall reception tower. But why isn't it reciprocated? Possibly just the concentration of stations at the shore areas. Nearly all of the Philly Class B's have a Class A adjacent here. 92.5 has WOBM 92.7. 93.3 has WDTH 93.1. 94.1 has WILW 94.3. 95.7 has LPFM 95.5. 98.1 has WTKU 98.3...it goes on and on. Lots of adjacent channel bleed and co channel signals from DE and MD. NYC has their Class B's covered with Docket 80-90 CLass A's.
In High School, I regularly listened to Tom McNally on Rock 104 WMGM in Pottstown on a Grundig table radio. WRNJ, WFPG-FM as well, with just the built-in "dipole". And I guess that was when WMGM was still side mounted on the short WOND tower. I couldn't wait for the spots and ID's to show off what a long pull-in I had. But it only could be pulled in in the elevated North End of town, and along the Schuylkill River at the Mrs. Smith's Pie Company at the south end! Otherwise you needed a yagi and rotor. (sorry to give up your age Tom)
I don't know if this is the real reason, but it's plausable.