landtuna said:
melan8tr said:
C'mon guys....it's not just the music...it's the movies today..TV today.....Magazines ..OMG! the intranet..it's 2013
quite classifing RAP as the root of all evil today...
I may have missed it but I cannot recall anyone accusing rap as the "root of all evil". It is, particularly among certain ethnic groups a major contributor.
melan8tr said:
compare the classifieds of a 1955 newspaper and then go to craigs list where you can buy anything drugs, sex, viagra, and worse..my god you guys talk like the world stood still except for RAP...
You are comparing apples to oranges. Newspapers are a regulated business operating by a series of laws and requirements, including having professional editors and publishers. Craigslist is an electronic kiosk with none of those.
Comparing a 1955 newspaper with one today finds almost the sole difference being some mildly erotic ads that would not have been published in the 50's but even that depends upon the market. Big city newspapers always tended to be much more liberal than others. Other than the obvious technical improvements such as color there are no significant differences.
melan8tr said:
it's a progression and If I have to dig and find examples of profanity, homophobia, misogmy, murder, suicide and every thing you all have cited in RAP I can find the same in todays rock and POP, ....
I do not listen to today's Rock and Pop so I won't argue this point other than to say I don't hear the very vocal and widespread criticism of Rap in the other genres.
melan8tr said:
and I am sorry but the majority of the kids love it.
Actually they don't. According to "Preferred music genres among U.S. teenage internet users as of August 2012"
http://www.statista.com/statistics/245743/preferred-music-genres-among-teenagers-in-the-us/ and many other sources Rap is in 7th place with a bit over 7% of teens regularly listening. It is the bottom of what we would call the popular genres of music.
Back to LandTuna's survey for a moment...I decided to risk having my inbox filled with spam and registered for a free account.
That unlocked the source of the survey: Stageoflife.com. It's a self-described "literacy initiative" that has a writing contest each month, for which there's a small prize (movie tickets, unidentified swag and "exposure in our news release about the winner"). In addition, anyone entering the contest each month has to take a survey. The "musical preferences of teens" survey was what you had to do if you wanted to enter the August, 2012 Teen Writing Contest (they have 10 monthly contests sorted by life stages, Teen, Getting Married, Starting A Family, Retirement, etc.).
Stageoflife.com has been around for 5 years. In its annual report (published on the founder's blog), they say they got about 350,000 page views last year. So it's small.
And of that group of people, 413 teens wanted to write an essay and had to answer questions first.
Well, maybe 413 people. You can enter twice. And it looks like you take the survey each time.
Again, the big problem (past the unscientific, tiny sample from a small universe) is the question:
"If you could only listen to one genre of music for the rest of your life, what would it be?"
The number one answer was "Pop" at 18.4%. That's 76 votes. Hip-Hop/Rap appears to be way down the list at 7.9%...but that translates to 30 votes. Pretty healthy. Almost half as many of these teens would choose rap or hip-hop as the only music to listen to the rest of their life as chose pop (which, the past 23 years or so, includes a considerable hip-hop influence).
When you look at the responses to the question "What's the last song you listened to?", there's a fair amount of hip-hop there.
Ultimately, too small a group to represent the tastes of young America. Since Billboard has Soundscan and accurately measures music purchases (both physical and download), sales figures and CHR/Rhythmic CHR radio ratings in the Top 50 markets would give a much better picture of teenagers' appreciation of Hip-Hop.
It's more than 7.9%.