David, are you channeling Mario500? I obviously meant that ratings had been adversely impacted by the departure of this DJ, which created a financial issue through lower revenue leading Emmis to have to trim costs which they achieved through a staff reduction. In other words, "You think?!?"
No, David's statement is correct. The departure of a DJ, even one as popular as KPWR's Big Boy, does not automatically lead all by itself to ratings drops and a corresponding drop in revenue. As he points out, the whole station took a hit in the ratings from KRRL, and it looks like the only advantage stealing the morning guy did for iHeart was to draw more attention to the new station. They could have lost the lawsuit, had the injunction that prevented Big Boy from going on the air, and still taken a hit in the ratings.
KPWR suffers from what I call "KHJ syndrome" ... they hit the top of the ratings book consistently for several years, then forgot to freshen the format. Eventually, the station sounded tired ... to the audience they became "old Power 106", just as KHJ started sounding old and predictable by the 1970s. When iHeart sensed the opportunity to flip 92.3 to take on 105.9 formatically, they nicely timed it to a point in time where Kurt was at a contract negotiation point*, then made their move.
The high profile lawsuit surrounding Big Boy got Real 92.3 more publicity than a format flip normally would have, and I'd bet they were prepared to go it without him if they lost. Remember, this is a company that owned the highest billing CHR in America and replaced its beloved high-profile morning guy after decades of ruling the book, and suffered no appreciable damages. Of course, I'm talking about KIIS-FM and Rick Dees ... and you'll note the replacement guy is still there.
I think iHeart had every scenario possible worked out. The morning show was a potentially disposable element.
*-For those who wonder how iHeart would know that, do you really think Big Boy didn't go talk to them at his previous renewal point? They knew since at least then when the opportunity would present itself again.