Voice of Reason,
Let me clarify myself a bit here. I like Mat Diablo. I agree that he's definitely the best 91X has. In fact, I listen to 91X in the mornings on my way to work, and some combination of 101.5 (which has, imo, the best DJs in San Diego), 105.3, and XX 1090 the rest of the day. I actually like the sidekick trio of Carlos, Sammi and Preston, though I doubt any of them would be nearly as entertaining without Diablo playing ringmaster.
I did like Mahoney. He was often an inflammatory element, and the rants he and Diablo would coax out of each other were a good deal of fun. You're right, the show has gone on without him, and like you, I doubt that it would have continued had Mahoney been the one kept. I still enjoyed his rants, though, and he was better at pissing Diablo off than any of the current goofballs are.
As to the rest of the 91X crew, Mookie seems like a nice-enough guy, but he's blah as a DJ. I miss Steve West. Christy Taylor is like nails on a freakin' chalkboard, and her habit of ending every sentence with "91X?" makes me want to take a shotgun to my radio, am I right 91X? Capone might as well be the male equivalent of Taylor--he's every bit as hyperactive and annoying.
It's one thing if one station intern lands an on-air spot when their internship ends. It's something else entirely when all three morning show sidekicks and the midday guy started out as interns--and it suggests that the station is looking for talent on the cheap. I also find it somewhat comical (in a sad way) that Mat Diablo regularly jokes that everyone at 91X has to hold down a second job to stay afloat--and actually means it.
And no, for future reference, I'm not Mahoney, although Diablo did refer to me as a "kindred spirit" of his when I called in last year to request a song that I hate be played purely to piss another listener off.
