They may have an established product and a brand behind them which Merlin did not have, but I predict ratings only slightly better than Merlin's news format. I suppose the Ad revenue will keep the format on that frequency longer than the dismal ratings will. If they really wanted spoken word on FM they would have been wiser to have a local news talk format instead which I suspect would do better than sports talk.
Seriously?! Only slightly better than Merlin's news format? Does anyone remember that FM News got a .6?! I think everyone can agree that WFAN will get at least in the mid-2's.
Sports bills much better than local news talk. Look at the billing of WABC (yeah, it's not local but it's news/talk) vs. WFAN. There are all of your answers. Stop looking at the ratings and start looking at the billing numbers to figure out what formats are going where.
I don't think WFAN will get dismal ratings on 101.9. Most likely they will improve. The Fan has been around for 25 years, people know it and have a listening relationship with the hosts. FM News was a hack job from day 1, competing with 2 well established all news stations. The only other competition that WFAN has in the sports format is WEPN, and they don't have the same "NY Feel" that WFAN has.
You just sound mad because the stop-gap rock format is going away.