AC Tones said:
Agreed, Cat. Not sure how this gets accomplished. History is not on our side, but there are obviously dynamics at work to which we are not privy that MIGHT be indicative of a real and fundamental change in philosophy.
Or, simply, you are trying to make wishes into reality. Cat theorized that "getting out from under the shadow" of Clear Channel would allow new programming directions, even though it is widely known that BA was operationally autonomous from Clear and guided by the research they themselves did, not by corporate dictates that said, "play more Stevie Wonder."
My chief concern is that there still will be unrealistic expectations to generate ad revenue and ratings for a format that historically has produced neither
Now that is just false. KTWv in the past was among the top 4 or 5 stations in revenue, and was often in the very top tier in ratings, too. In San Diego, KIFM has often been a ratings and revenue leader in the past, although now it's billing is not even top-10. The format did deliver big numbers in the past, and many SJ stations were in the top 5 or 6 in billings.
Example: 2000. WNUA, Chicago. 4th 25-54, 6th 12+, 5th in revenue.
(therefore, the pressure to placate advertisers will continue to drive programming choices).
The pressure is to offer to advertisers a medium with enough listeners to be of interest. An advertiser is not "placated." Larger advertisers simply pick in each market the top stations in audience delivery, and generally go no deeper. There is no art in this... it's about delivering lots of consumers at a reasonable cost per consumer.
Any new approach should be inclusive of a free and open exchange of dialogue,
And that dialogue should be between the stations and their listeners, not a "panel of experts" that decides what is "coorrect" smooth jazz.
We call that "research."
but it also needs to get back to the principles that this format is survivable and viable if sold as a "lifestyle" and not as a huge moneymaker.
Advertisers buy ears, not taste. In this sense, SJ competes with hip hop, CHR, AC, oldies, classic hits, classic rock, country, urban, urban AC, Regional Mexican, Tropical, news/talk, Sports, NPR and all the other radio formats on the dial.