wheatstone said:
A. What about all the advertisers in Wilmington who don't want to reach Philadelphia (or pay Philly rates) to promote their businesses? Would Happy Harry's, Nucar and Concord Pet be better off spending their ad dollars on B101 and WMMR or WSTW and WJBR? The latter would have to charge a lot more than they do now if they were to become Philadelphia metro stations. I'm not sure who would be served by such a move. Maybe the poor Philadelphia stations that you seem so eager to protect and promote. Do you own a lot of Clear Channel stock or something? Maybe you're friends with the last few remaining air personalities in Philly.
B. Using this logic Gannett should fold its tent and just reprint the Philadelphia Inquirer for distribution in Delaware. Since no one is interested in local news or sports down there... And WDEL and WILM, just turn them off too. Since no one cares, no one will notice. 1060 is all you need.
C. Of course the markets were set up when AM was king and there were less than half the stations on the air as we have today. Weren't most markets defined in the 60's and 70's? Also, don't forget that Chester County used to be part of the Wilmington Metro.
I'm sorry, Wheat. I was about to type that what you wrote was the most irrational argument I've ever seen. On second thought, it resembles the kind of emotional and unreasoned arguments people used against:
1. The Equal Rights Amendment (Everybody would have to use the same bathroom).
2. Smoke Free Laws (Would kill the restaurant business)
3. Bring back the Fairness Doctrine (Would destroy talk radio and free speech)
The more I see some of the responses to the idea of letting radio markets reflect reality, the more convinced I become that the blogger who first noticed the discrepancy between Arbitron markets and official MSA definitions might be on to something.
Let me respond to the points you raised:
A. Wilmington advertisers would still have three currently active AM stations to target a smaller and more specific geographic area. However, Concord and Happy Harry do have stores in Pennsylvania and car dealers typically market to a fairly large geographic area. The signal of Wilmington's two FMs is a regional signal and right now most of their signal coverage is being wasted (and potential revenue is curtailed).
The Wilmington market as Arbitron now defines it also includes Salem and Cecil Counties. How Cecil got in there I have no idea because people there are oriented to Baltimore and the strongest AM signal comes from York. In any case, neither county gets any attention from the Wilmington stations. Wilmington's rim-shot FM stations might actually have to go back to serving Kent and Harford, their home counties, too (instead of trying to "move in" to Wilmington and trying to con advertisers into believing their signals actually provide decent coverage of Wilmington).
Again, when somebody says something you don't want to hear, you attack their (supposed) motives.
B. New Castle County has a population comparable to Delaware and Chester Counties and much smaller than Bucks and Montgomery Counties. Those counties have daily newspapers and AM stations covering local news and local events and targeting their home counties for advertisers (i.e., WCOJ, WNPV, WBCB).
If the Inquirer began producing a targeted edition for New Castle County, including an NCC local news section, this would in my view be a benefit and not a problem for New Castle County. The News-Journal is a disgrace. Even though the Inquirer is not the paper it was in the 70s, 80s and early 90s, it remains far superior to Gannett's McPaper. If you don't like Clear Channel, how can you support it's equivalent in the newspaper world?
And finally, there's the point (which someone else made originally) that if Arbitron redrew their markets to correspond to the official definitions, Wilmington would still probably be reported on it's own
and as part of the Philly Metro as an embedded market. Places like Long Island, San Jose and Frederick are embedded markets and radio is still alive and well in those areas. Just like, Delaware's smoke-free restaurants are doing just fine, filled with people who can taste their dinners and don't go home with smoke-smell on their clothes.