> I'd love to see AOR back in B'ham., but it never has worked.
> Count the stations that have tried it. K-99, 95 rock, Planet
> Rock 92.5, and even K-Rock (AM 1010) and if you want to go
> way back there was WJLN 104.7. So good luck if somebody
> does try it.
Not necessarily....
Unless I'm mistaken, WJLN changed to C&W after K-99 went on the air.
WVOK-FM/WRKK K-99 was a fantastic, well-programmed, locally aware AOR. Remember the heavy competition they had with KICKS 106 in the 1979-81 period? In 1980, K-99 was ranked #6 in the nation in the Rolling Stone poll's "favorite radio station" category. Nobody could say K-99 "never worked."
95 ROCK was little more than a clone of sister station WABB-FM in Mobile -- which at the time called itself 97 ROCK. It was your typical "Superstars"-style AOR, in the mold of Atlanta's 96 ROCK and Memphis' ROCK 103. Problem was, B'ham couldn't support two AORs. K-99 went country in August 1982, after Brennan sold it. 95 ROCK then had AOR all to itself until 1984.
But 95 ROCK didn't change due to bad ratings; remember how it took close to a year before it completely transitioned to CHR I-95? Look at Dittman flagship WABB-FM, which did the very same thing at the very same time! 97 ROCK became 97-FM. Dittman's stations (Birmingham, Mobile, Memphis) all used the same formula.
K-ROCK (WPYK) had a crummy signal over B'ham ... it was a daytimer out of Dora, fer cryin' out loud! That didn't last but, what, six months? Now, doing AOR on AM wasn't entirely folly ... look no further than other Ala. stations rocking out in the '80s: WLSQ 950 "95 ROCK" in Montgomery (1980-87), WOOF 560 "ROCKIN' 56" in Dothan (1984-88) and the first WTAK in Huntsville, AM 1000 (1987-93).
My take is that Birmingham wants a good AOR station, but except for K-99 and early (1988-90) ROCK 99, hasn't had one. ROCK 99 started out in the mold of K, but quickly degenerated into a 20-song playlist. I suspect that was timid management -- remember that for a long time AOR had that "you can't sell it, it only appeals to hippies" baggage.
What I'd love to see in B'ham is an adult rock format, more or less AAA currents mixed with the older, deeper classic rock, call it "K-(frequency)" and you'll get some big adult numbers. And hey -- for added fun, flip 610 to oldies and call it WXGN.

(and raise Jim Taber from the dead to program it!!)
But no, I don't think it's a case of AOR not being successful in the 'Ham; IMHO except for K-99 it was a case of the wrong owners with the wrong stations at the wrong time.
My .02 (forgive the tarnished pennies, it's all I could find under the cushion)
*********
Russell W.
Savannah, Ga.
Birmingham native and wembaster of Birmingham Rewound:
http://mywebpages.comcast.net/bham.rewound