WNTIRadio said:
True, but look at WTOP in Washington. Like WINS, they had it on an AM signal that didn't cover the whole metro due to a directional pattern that was designed before the population spread outside the city. They put it on an FM with a full market signal and it is one of the top billers in the country.
WINS is all but useless west of the city at night. Even an improvement to 660 would help it.
WFAN would have the "prestige" of being on an FM. Of course that means the Mets are on an FM and the Yankees are not. But in any case, the billing WILL go up.
Merlin failed because the product was crap, unfocused and changed its approach every month. And there were already two excellent all news products in the market with four and a half decades of heritage each. Putting Brand X cola on in the front of the store still won't make it sell any better if Coke and Pepsi are there and taste way better. Or if Bloom-nutrition-nazi-berg decides you can't sell them anymore...
You are correct! Product is the only thing that matters.
WKTU and Z-100 did not just kick butt when they came on because they were on FM, they offered something that people wanted.
I did not have an opportunity to hear "FM News" in its native environment, since it did not last that long. I sampled them, and with a News station, it isn't fair to make a judgement based solely on a sample. But, I do know WINS, since WINS is a "Pavlov's dog" of a product - and the only game in town, for the town - I would say, they could put that signal on WNYZ and it would have listeners better than an upstart stand alone FM.
This PPM is something of a mystery to me when it comes to methodology and implementation over traditional books and phone calls. In New York, there are just too many commuters and travelers in and out of the signal of Empire for there to be an accurate consistent sample. WINS, even with its signal deficiencies, is still a 50,000 signal and outruns the FM's. But, you don't have consistent FM signal inside the Subways for FM, either. If you live on the opposite (south-eastern) side of the building in Brooklyn, you are going to have a problem if you live below the 10th floor. That is true with the south sides of buildings in Lower Manhattan. Add short-spacing to that.
None of these problems exist, in magnitude, in other markets to be a factor.
I can't help but wonder what the radio discussion landscape would look like if we had adopted Kahn's system...
Jeff in Sa-ra-so-ta!