This is heading down a slippery slope. What is a meteorologist and what qualifies one to carry that title? There is no standard definition. It not like having an MD or passing the bar. There is no clear cut definition. In general people who have a degree in meteorology from an accredited meteorology program are considered to be a meteorologist. Besides the tests and work experience, the AMS seal requires a degree in meteorology. The NWA seal program does not. It requires less work experience and no degree, but the test and the continuing education/testing requirements are fairly tough. Good meteorology programs include Florida State, Mississipi State, Penn State, Cornell, Lyndon State in Vermont, Oswego State in New York, Umass-Lowell, Mit, Colorado. There is not all that many to be honest. The degrees are tough programs to get through. Lots of physics, chemistry, and calculus. That is why the people with the degrees tend to look down at those who call themselves meteorologists, but don't have the degrees. In the end it comes down to are you a good forecaster, not the degree you have, not the seals you have, not your title. How you interpret model data, how you apply that data to current atmospheric conditions, your sense of weather history and trends in your forecast area, it all converges to help make you a good forecaster.