Hopefully, at least New York's Country 94.7 HD2 will continue. Unlike Alt on 92.3 HD2 and Smooth Jazz on 102.7 HD2, it has a steady sponsor, and also clears Audacy's national Country programming.
That goes back to the cliche that one needs to put in money to make money. New York's Country is a less common situation where they kept programming along with the music, when they moved the format to HD2/3. Most cases are like Alt, where they simply move the music format to the HD2/3 and cut all other programming. My theory is the following:
- Listeners are told that the station they liked wasn't financially viable to remain as is, but go out and buy a HD Radio, car with a HD radio, or go onto the Audacy app to hear the music without any of the shows that also drew them to the station. There are people who state that HD Radio is growing and/or beginning to thrive. I just don't agree. Then with streaming, streaming the likes of Alt out of New York is inferior, as it's music, some commercials, and the Alt 92.3 HD-2 station identification. Why stream that, when I can stream the music from another source (Apple Music, Spotify, Pandora), or I can go to the likes of another Alt station (ie. Alt 98.7 from LA) where I can hear the music with programming. To the listener, the HD2/3 as a streaming resource is inferior to other options. With New York's Country, the listener still gets a product that is (more) unique to the station, giving the audience a greater reason to follow. That investment helps retain a larger audience, which attracts sponsors.
- I have to also acknowledge that of all the HD2/3 that you mention in New York, Country is the one format that Nationally is still attracting larger audiences. It was flipped in New York, but still has one plus stations across many markets. Alt on the other hand is struggling Nationally. It makes sense to clear New York with specific national shows on New York's Country, while not clearing Elliot on Alt.
- Then complete the issue with the common finding from many of the insiders on here, which is that formats like Alt are struggling to gain a consensus amongst listeners as to what they want. Just because Alt is now on HD2 doesn't mean that identity crisis of the format went away. Country doesn't have that identity crisis amongst its fans.
I theorize that without the large install base for HD Radio, along with multiple competing platforms and mediums, I don't see HD Radio as something that will survive. Had it been rolled out in large numbers a decade earlier, I would have a different outlook on it, but it was launched in the same general era of the launch of the smart phone, which brought streaming to a whole new level. Streaming on desktops/laptops already existed prior to HD Radio. The smart phone simply expedited streaming's rise to dominance.
Then financially, cellphone manufacturers and providers alsa ensured that streaming would dominate. Ten years ago, users could buy Android models with activated FM radio. To my knowledge, the iPhone never had it; yet I never owned an iPhone, so I'm not 100% certain. Then, I theorized that it would be nothing for later models to include HD Radio. I failed to recognize that 1.) They would have to pay royalties to include HD Radio, 2.) FM radio is free, where streaming uses data, and 3.) With companies making their own streaming apps, it was more probable that they would push streaming over an inferior OTA signal cutting in and out. Instead of seeing HD Radio added, we saw the expediting of streaming.
Just my lone outsider take on this interesting thread.