> > > The X in BR is too
> > > 'all over the place' for me...they may go from Metallica
>
> > to
> > > a pop radio Good Charlotte song.
> >
> > I'm an avid listener to the X - its the best we've got
> > around here, even if it lacks real personalities - and
> > neither of those bands are played. (I couldn't be
> happier,
> > btw.) You need to tune in more. You don't seem to
> > understand what modern/alt.'s modus operandi is. Variety
> is
> > what the good alt stations do. KROQ in L.A. is the best
> > example of this.
> >
>
> I haven't listened to KROQ so I can't base it on anything I
> haven't really heard, But when Rock 93.7 was going, The X
> went more alternative lean with now almost 3 months later,
> since actually reading one of your post burnout, I started
> listeneing again and the X has seemed to go back to the
> original formula of more mainstream rock with the
> alternative. They have gotten better again but I do agree on
> the personality but you got to remember that this is
> Guaranty we are talking about and last I heard, they were
> using this station as a bonus for buying ad time on WDGL
> 98.1
>
>
> > > One could argue that Good
> > > Charlotte belongs on an alternative station, and they
> do,
> > > but CHR currents from alternative artists DO NOT.
> >
> > At one time, Smells Like Teen Spirit was a CHR #1. Why
> > should alt stations be ripe for the picking of CHR and AC
> > stations when they will drop those artists like hot
> potatoes
> > when the new Eminem and Britney records come out? I
> listen
> > to alt/modern stations because I like that style of music
> > and I don't listen to CHR stations at all. I shouldn't be
>
> > deprived of good songs within my own favorite genre just
> > because other stations got a clue momentarily.
> >
>
> I agree with burnout on this one, espcailly since CHR has
> picked up on the alternative scene again (after playing
> almost no songs save for three doors down and one or two
> others for mostly urban in recent times).
> Besides, when they go for adds on the CHR, they are usually
> in the top 10 already on the rock charts basically so does
> that mean I drop a top 10 song cause CHR got wind it's a
> good song? I think not.
>
> RFLA
>
I'm afraid my original post was taken somewhat out of context. I was merely suggesting that it is frustrating when rock stations continue playing a song (in frequent rotation) that CHR stations are beating to death. Recent examples: Mr. Brightside, Somebody Told Me, & The Reason. I wasn't suggesting they shouldn't be played at all, but with much less frequency.
Also, The "X" is sounding better. My apologies for not giving credit.