IMO, WNCI and The Blitz when it comes to imaging and overall presentation. I also gotta give Radio U credit for great imaging with such a small, non-profit operation. They sound so much bigger than they are.
Mix, but more importantly, the formats Hot AC and Adult CHR have bothered me as of late. It feels like they're trying to be all things to all people but it just doesn't work. I enjoy the majority of the songs on their station, but I just can't hear them next to each other. To me, playing Bittersweet Symphony followed by Dynamite just doesn't flow. You're going from a slower tempo, emotional, self-loathing message delivered by multi-instrumentalists to an up-tempo, superficial, self-celebratory message delivered by electronic, auto-tuned, digitally perfect computers. I get it's a mix, but it just doesn't have a vibe anymore.
To me, the hot ac / mix formats worked through much of the 2000s when at least the instrumentation between the styles was the same: electric guitar, bass, drums, piano/keys, and vocals. Whether alternative or pop, singer/songwriter or AC ballad, those instruments were pretty standard. Today, you're talking 808 drums, synths, pads, and auto-tune. The messaging has changed too. Modern songs are written almost as an escape of reality. Between "Good Life", "Party Rock Anthem", and "Last Friday Night", do any of the new artists know there's a recession going on?
I digress... I'm just saying that the transition between these songs is more than just stylistic. Times have changed. Alternative was almost 20 years ago. 115-120 BPM dance-pop is in. Maybe some change or new research is in order. Or maybe it's just one guy's opinion...
