• Get involved.
    We want your input!
    Apply for Membership and join the conversations about everything related to broadcasting.

    After we receive your registration, a moderator will review it. After your registration is approved, you will be permitted to post.
    If you use a disposable or false email address, your registration will be rejected.

    After your membership is approved, please take a minute to tell us a little bit about yourself.
    https://www.radiodiscussions.com/forums/introduce-yourself.1088/

    Thanks in advance and have fun!
    RadioDiscussions Administrators

Best/Worst CT News Station and/or CT stations rank

In this thread, please rank first the best to worst Connecticut (Hartford/New Haven DMA) TV station. I'm talking about 3, 8, 30, and 61.

Also, please rank all these stations in addition to 20 and 59 as far as quality and programming. I am curious on everyone's opinions, so please be specific and honest. Thanks!
 
Including or besides network content?

Overall with network content, I'd go with

30 (I watch NBC the most, but Channel 3's local news is the best in the state IMO)
3
8
61
20
59

Assuming we're only counting those 6 channels.
 
WCTX-TV/DT (MY) channel 59/D 39 will no longer be viewed by yours truly, unless they air Yankees games again next season. "WWE Smackdown!" and "Veronica Mars" are now on CW (channel 20). It's just like WHPX-TV/DT (I) channel 26/D 34 New London a few years ago when they once aired Yankees games from WPIX and had several pro wrestling shows. As soon as that all went away, so did my interest in channel 26.

As for news, channel 30 gives a good presentation. I'd like channel 3's much more if they weren't so over-the-top with their current presentation. Channel 8 will always be an also-ran third place in Hartford County. At 10 PM, I'll likely be watching WTIC-TV and their FOX 61 News At 10 (forget the simulcast on channel 20). I don't remember the last time I watched the channel 8-produced 10 PM news on channel 59.
 
News I'd go with:

3
8
30
61/20
59

Channel 61 news seems to be getting cheaper and cheaper, which is sad because it used to be excellent.. 59 just doesn't rate for me news-wise. 30 seems a bit too cheesy and full of fluff. 3 and 8 are battling it out for the top spot with 3 taking it for now IMO.
 
Here is how I rank them:

3
30
8
61 and 20
59

WFSB is first because they do a great job with news and I like watching the CBS programs. WVIT is second because their news is second best and the programs are good, watched more on Sunday now as NBC has the NFL back. WTNH third, don't really care for their news, is watched sometimes for ABC programing. WTIC and WTXX both great channels as they both show UCONN basketball. FOX 61 news is alright and the FOX programing is good I like many of the shows. As for WCTX its never watched did back in the day when WCTX had Red Sox.
 
Strictly speaking from a NEWS standpoint:

(It’s kind of silly to say a news station is better because YOU like to watch “Desperate Housewives” instead of “Survivor” or “American Idol”)

WFSB-CBS Eywitness News 3: Still the number one rated news station in CT. Very good with scattering their crews around the state and covering as much as possible. Nice new graphics and pretty solid talent. Although sometimes I feel they can get a little bit “tabloid-ish” and over dramatic at times, especially with breaking news from other parts of the country that have nothing to do with CT. Overall, they do a good job.

WTNH-ABC Newschannel 8: The solid number two news station and rising. The have very solid anchor teams and reporters and are the most experienced in the market. A nice “no-nonsense”, less “fluff”, straight forward newscast with its content and delivery. Also, they are the only station in the market with a chopper which adds a lot to their breaking news coverage. However, I would like to see them do a better job of changing up their daily newscasts instead of basically showing the same broadcast at 6, 10 and 11.

WVIT-NBC 30 News: A former top contender that continues to slide. Things aren’t going well over at 30. Some good talent mixed in with a lot of “kids” with little or no experience. They have a serious identity crisis with just about all of their anchor teams. Everyone seems to be trying to hard and the revolving door does little to help with on-air consistency. From what I have heard, it’s a total mess inside the newsroom with hiring freezes and major staffing shortages in many areas.

WTIC-FOX 61: The local college station. Don’t get me wrong, with the little money and resources they have 61 manages to put a decent show on the air. However, I can’t really view them as a real “player” or major competitor in CT since they only manage to put 1 hour of news on-air a day. A morning show or even a 10AM show to go up against 30 is much needed. Until they put something on the air other than just the “News at 10” PM, I can’t take them seriously.
 
broadwayjoe said:
WFSB-CBS Eywitness News 3: Still the number one rated news station in CT. Very good with scattering their crews around the state and covering as much as possible. Nice new graphics and pretty solid talent. Although sometimes I feel they can get a little bit “tabloid-ish” and over dramatic at times, especially with breaking news from other parts of the country that have nothing to do with CT. Overall, they do a good job.

WTNH-ABC Newschannel 8: The solid number two news station and rising. The have very solid anchor teams and reporters and are the most experienced in the market. A nice “no-nonsense”, less “fluff”, straight forward newscast with its content and delivery. Also, they are the only station in the market with a chopper which adds a lot to their breaking news coverage. However, I would like to see them do a better job of changing up their daily newscasts instead of basically showing the same broadcast at 6, 10 and 11.

I have to agree.

This is why I say that WTNH-8 should be first. NewsChannel 8 does the best job in covering Connecticut, in market and out of market. No other station covers Fairfield County as well, whether it be Stratford, Stamford, Bethel or Bridgeport. At the same time, WTNH is constantly covering news in the eastern part of the state, with the New London newsroom at the Day. I also think WTNH's bread & butter is Litchfield County, Greater Waterbury, the Naugatuck Valley, Greater Danbury, and then of course the I-91 New Haven-Hartford corridor. In terms of news coverage, they're literally everywhere! WFSB doesn't venture much to the south or west of Southington, and likewise, both WFSB and WVIT are weak along the coast and in Fairfield County. WTNH puts its NewsChopper 8 to good use, something none of the other stations have or can compete with. WTNH is also superior in terms of traffic coverage and politics. Aboveall, WTNH airs what someone else called "no-nonsense news" most of the time. The content of their newscasts is concise and hardly sensational. The only thing WTNH suffers from is the constantly recurring problem of weird things happening to the audio, graphics, and cameras when they're live from the studio or field. But I think the fault, albeit no less annoying, is due to human error at master control in Springfield, Mass.

I would say that WVIT-30 would be the second best newsstation in the state. With the exception of their morning team, most of their evening news personalities are veterans in the state (Gerry Brooks, JoAnne Nesti, Janet Peckinpaugh, and Brad Field). Speaking of Brad Field, I think the NBC30 weather crew is of the most qualified in the state. They have the most accurate forecasts, and actually used to "guarantee" their weather with a prize of sorts. They're also strong in their sports coverage. Although not veterans in Connecticut, Kevin Nathan and Persephone Contos (who also worked at WTNH) have done a great job at establishing themselves in the market. They're also the most active in community events, along with Brooks and Nesti, whether it's the GHO (what do they call it now?) or the Pilot Pen. The few negative aspects of WVIT include their tendency to be a bit tabloid, as well as the high turnover of reporters. I couldn't tell you who is left as a news reporter there. The last reporter I actually liked was Lisa Salvati, but she only lasted a few months and was gone at the beginning of the summer.

WFSB has to be last among the 'big three', in my eyes. I already mentioned their poor coverage of news (either live or late breaking) throughout all parts of Connecticut. They tend to focus on Hartford and Middlesex Counties and eastward. What really gets me going is the fact that they have this news segment which they constantly flaunt, called "Town By Town." Unfortunately, they jump around the state, usually reporting about four towns at a time, and give a small briefing on something happening there, all in less than one minute. The most perverse thing about it is that these are stories that happened days or even weeks ago. I think WFSB scans the wire or state newspapers, then sends out a videographer to get a small clip, and then the anchor does a voiceover. But it's always old news. It's a sorry way to try to get viewers and make people feel that WFSB truly covers every town in Connecticut. It's just too absurd. With the exception of Al Terzi, Denise D'Ascenzo, Bruce DePrest and Kevin Hogan, WFSB lacks a lot in terms of quality personalities. They've had huge turnover in terms of sports personalities over the years - maybe this Joe Zone guy will actually buck the trend. Watching the morning show is like being at the circus sometimes, who knows, maybe some people like that kind of stuff when they watch the news. But to me, it's all too fluffy and not worth watching. Their weather crew is not as established as WVIT's, but I think they can build themselves up well in a few years. Another thing is their flashiness and sensationalism. They tend to report more crime/shooting stories than any other station in Connecticut. Nationally, they like to report especially on car chases in California, stupid criminals and bank robberies in the midwest, and stories involving wildanimals in the south. You can find this kind of stuff before and/or after the weather and sports segments. And a small pet peeve of mine is the fact that they tend to pair up Dennis House and Kara Sundlun during the primetime newsshows. I like Al Terzi and Denise D'Ascenzo better, but Terzi, being Connecticut's most veteran news anchor, tends to work a lot less these days. And Dennis House replaced him at 6 & 11. I assume it's only a matter of time before they offer D'Ascenzo some kind of better schedule, since she's been there forever, and replace her with Sundlun. Most people probably could care less, but I just think there's something wrong with putting House and Sunlun next to each other at the anchor desk since they're husband and wife. Many corporations that I've worked at actually had policies on interoffice dating.

Of course, WTIC comes last. I don't have anything against FOX61, but I think it's not much better today than it was ten years ago. They just don't have the talent that they used to. Their news department was more qualified and serious in the mid 90s (i.e., Beth Carroll and Pat Sheehan) than it is today. I think Rich Coppola is the only worthwhile personality from the old school that they have left. Their weather coverage was more accurate and detailed in the mid 90s than it is today, with all the modern forecasting technologies and graphics at their disposition. The talent just isn't there. Don't get me wrong, it's not bad for a FOX affiliate in a smaller market. But I think they reached a crossroads a few years ago when they were in their prime. They had the opportunity to further develop their brand, possibly start a morning, noon, or evening newscast. But it didn't happen, and now the last few years has seen a downward spiral of quality, in my own opinion.

But I still watch all four stations regardless. Thanks to my recording devices and remote control I get a good survey of each news department and thus gather my opinions that way. No station's news coverage is so bad as that I wouldn't ever watch it. Every station works hard at what it does and they all deserve fair credit. Hartford-New Haven, as a whole, is actually superior to some other larger markets in terms of local news from what I've seen and heard. So despite some of my harsh critiqueing, we're still fortunate to have what all four stations are offering us.
 
master control has nothing to do with newscast graphics or audio or whatever. master control only switches between the newscats and commercials and nothing more. unless they have it set up different in new haven, i believe they are using parkervision which 'automates' the newscast and is the likely cause of failure.
 
I don't understand why WTNH spends so much time in Fairfield County. It is the NY market. If they concentrated on the rest of the state, they might someday overtake WFSB. The present strategy of covering Bridgeport and Fairfield won't work. It might help get a couple of advertisers, but not viewers.
Their Hartford bureau should be streetside, so they can get additional viewers. Thousands of cars drive by WFSB every day, but they are moving out of the city. WTNH needs a bureau that is seen by people, not just a pretty shot of the skyline.

WVIT needs ratings help, too. They have plenty of good, young talent that needs to be promoted: Tarantal, Rudat, Carberg, etc. Why have they waited so long to hire a 6PM anchor? The current solo anchored newscast is doing terrible in the ratings.
 
I think all 4 are horrible! ;D

WFSB - Because of their 3 Ring Circus in the morning. And their 12 minute newscast Sunday and Friday Night at 11PM. Yeah that's right 12 Minutes. Fridays from 11PM-1112PM they do the news and then they do Friday High School Sports WrapUp 11:15PM-11:35PM. Sundays the news is on 11PM-11:12PM and they do Sports Wrapup With Joe Zone from 11:15-11:30. It features the best sports highlights of the week.

WVIT - Because of their 10AM Newscast. - It is unnessary in my opinion.

WTNH - Basically I hate their traffic set up.

WTIC-TV - Need I say more?
 
Holy hicksville Batman!

You guys actually have a sportscaster named Joe Zone?!?!? Who's the main anchor - Ron Burgundy? :D
 
Now, I will rate them.

I don't like the news period anymore. It has become too full of reporters and anchors who think they are celebrities from Hollywood. The formats of the news are terrible. The meterologists make me insane 9they just can't tell you the weather. When it's going to rain, they tell you the day will be unbearable, and same with cloudy. That's no way to get people's day started. Finally, the bus stop weather is cartoonish and unnecessary).

WFSB is the best news station in my opinion despite everything I said. I don't have many problems with the on-air staff.

WTNH is next. They have great professional anchors, and a good website. I also like the 8-Day forecast.

WVIT is OK, but I have been upset with some of their anchors. I liked Joanne Nesti and Gerry Brooks doing the evening news. They have been cut down to 11pm i think. I HATE the morning team. Brian Schatman is fine though, but Keisha Grant is fake. She reminds me of plastic. She tries to act too professional, and is annoying and not funny at all. I sware, she can stand there next to Brian and smile when an entire town is on fire. Finally, Bob Maxon is terribly unfunny, and annoys me to death, talking about schools and kids way too much.

WTIC can do better. They need something in the mornings, even if it's The Daily Buzz.

WTXX and WCTX need to stick with general entertainment, and their respective networks (CW/MY).
 
My last post, I broke it down by overall station ratings with their strengths and weakneses.

This time, I have broken things down in a different way. I have left WTIC out of this because with just one hour of news a day, 5 or 6 reporters and 1 live truck; they ARE NOT a serious news outlet in CT. They would rank last in just about every (if not all) categories anyway.

It looks like overall WTNH NewsChannel 8 is the overall market leader in just about all categories when you look at it this way. Feel free to chime in on the breakdown below:

Overall best news cast: (Solid reporting, overall CT area coverage, weather, traffic, sports, breaking news, overall local, national and world balance, all around presentation, etc.)
1-WTNH
2-WFSB
3-WVIT

Most experienced news anchors: (Both overall but most importantly in market)
1-WTNH
2-TIE to WFSB & WVIT

Most experienced reporters: (Both overall but most importantly in market)
1-WTNH (Also the MOST reporters in the state)
2-WFSB
3-WVIT

Most experienced Weather Team: (Both overall but most importantly in market)
1-WTNH (BY A LANDSLIDE!!!)
2-WVIT (Only because of Maxon and Field. The other two are kids.
3-WFSB (Sorry Bruce, Haney is a stand-up comic not a weatherman)

Best and most experienced Sports team:
1-WTNH (Experience and numbers)
2-WVIT
3-WFSB (Joe Zone??? What the hell is that?)

Best Overall Traffic: (Reporter, presentation, coverage etc.)
1- WTNH (By far, especially for coverage, presentation, cameras, maps, etc.)
2- TIE to WFSB & WVIT (DOT cameras and LIMITED coverage for both)

Best graphics, music and overall brand presentation:
1- TIE to WTNH & WFSB ( Only since 3 recently upgraded theirs)
2- WVIT

Best breaking news coverage:
1- WTNH (WHY? Simple - CHOPPER 8. No one else has one or can even compete)
2- WFSB
3- WVIT

Best facilities, equipment, technology etc.-
1-WTNH (by far first in the market with NLE, studio equipment, automation, cameras, etc.)
2-WFSB (second for now, but a new building on the way)
3-WVIT (have you seen 30’s building?! WTIC might actually beat them in this category!)

Live capability:
1-WTNH (BY A MILE! - 6 live trucks, 4 news bureaus, Metro Traffic live feed and the only News Helicopter and live Weather Vehicle in CT.)
2-WFSB (5-6 ENG trucks, and a bureau in New Haven)
3-WVIT (What a joke. They say they have a bureau at the Mystic Aquarium (why?) that I have never seen them use!)

Most Statewide News and Weather Live Cameras:
1-WTNH (AGAIN IN A LANDSLIDE)
2-WFSB
3-WVIT

Most Reporters/Field Crews:
1-WTNH
2-WFSB
3-WVIT

Best Coverage of the Hartford area:
1-WFSB
2-WVIT
3-WTNH ( One of a few places they need to improve)

Best Coverage of the New Haven area:
1-WTNH (Hands down-no contest)
2-WFSB
3-WVIT

Best Coverage of the New London area:
1-WTNH (Has a bureau and full time crew placed there)
2-WFSB
3-WVIT (How about that Mystic Aquarium studio…LOL!)

Best Coverage of the Bridgeport area: (YES, I know it’s technically not our market)
1-WTNH (again, NO CONTEST)
2-TIE to WFSB & WVIT (Bridgeport, anyone got a map?)
 
Let me just say I did rate the news, but I rarely watch it, and it's becoming even more rare, because they all are horrible wastes of time. If there's one story out of a half hour that means something to my life, it's a rare event. I'd rather read a newspaper or online for local news.

BBC News at 6 on WGBY 57 is the best on TV IMO though. 26 minutes, no commercials, and you've just learned what's happening in the world.
 
Here are some additional categories that I left out of my last post.

Looks like WTNH continues to dominate:

Best CT TV Station Website:
1-WTNH (AP Best Website award-More hits monthly than 3 and 30’s sites combined)
2-WFSB (Much improved since the last upgrade)
3-WVIT (BORING!-NBC O&O “cookie-cutter” site)

Best and most experienced Political Reporter:
1-WTNH (Mark Davis is the by far the best in the state)
2-WVIT (Tom Monahan is also very experienced and respected)
3-WFSB (???)

Best and most experienced Investigative Reporter:
1-WTNH (Alan Cohn has broken some major stories for 8)
2-WFSB (LOL, exactly which reporters are on the “I-Team”?)
3-WVIT (LOL again! Exactly which reporters are working at 30 this week? I’ve lost track!)

Feel free to post some other categories if you think of them.
 
I'm sorry, you may think I'm insane or stupid, but I hate the square they have around NBC30's logo when they display names. I know it's minor, but it looks out of place.
 
Besthoff is still there. With all the number 1 rankings you give WTNH, why do you think they can't be number 1 in ratings?
 
Status
This thread has been closed due to inactivity. You can create a new thread to discuss this topic.


Back
Top Bottom