Before this goes completely over into song lyrics, I will offer up a couple more examples of confusing town names. (And I did not type in "kyrie elaison" earlier, mainly because I did not know how to spell it!)
The town of Rives in west Tennessee, population, a few hundred at most. While I was working at the previously mentioned Martin station, we got a community announcement about a church in Rives holding a revival. Martin and Rives are in neighboring counties, so most "Martians" should have heard of Rives. Just to be on the safe side, I still wrote "Reeves" at the top of the card announcing the revival, but I believe I still heard it mispronounced. Yes it is possible to mispronounce a one-syllable name!
Then when we were on our trip to Pensacola, we passed through a small town just north of Pensacola which goes by the name Cantonment. Having no idea how to pronounce it, I jokingly called it "containment," although I assumed that the correct pronunciation was "cant-a-ment," or something like that. It was only upon our return trip to the Pensacola area this past spring that I learned that it was "can-TONE-ment."