Liberal talk radio was doomed before it started because it was never about the quality of programming, but as a way to “get back” at Rush, if that was even possible. Simple as that. It was fueled by bitterness, be it at Rush, or President Bush, or the Iraq War, or whatever. But bitterness is not entertaining in any way. I remember trying to listen to WCKY nighttime skywave when they tried liberal talk, and TBH I’ll never forget how utterly brutal Mike Malloy was on my ears. It was so off-putting and a chore to listen to.
When The Young Turks and Rachel Maddow bolted Air America for different platforms, being themselves and not doing a rather pointless parody of conservative talk radio, they thrived. Nobody remembers Jerry Springer’s near-disastrous stint as a talk show host, and thank god for that.
And unfortunately, much of talk radio on the conservative side subsequently lost the plot and failed to prevent themselves from approaching that levels of painfulness. I miss the Glenn Beck of 2005, which was genuinely entertaining… that Glenn Beck may never return. Sadly.