Tony, again I continue to admire your passion for improving the dance offering on Sirius. I admit I have not read through all the threads on that board, but it certainly seems you are in the minority of people who want to both a) bring back the Beat and b) fix BPM. I think you're sending a completely mixed signal by doing that or a variant of that. From what it seems, most people are on board with fixing BPM, however. It's the "bring back The Beat" part that is very disheartening. Again, Sirius won't dedicate bandwith to even dedicating channels to the different subgenres of Dance as they once did (e.g., breaks==boombox, trance=area, house=house party, ambient=chill). Why would they, then, dedicate two channels to the same positioning (dance hits)?? Regardless of your stand on what you want BPM to do, any executive who doesn't have more than a passing knwoledge of dance music (which I'm betting is all of them) will research The Beat adn find out its positioning is the same as BPM- that is, Dance Hits. They're going to say "appease these fans by making BPM MORE like The Beat". That's the only net effect I see this "campaign" having.
The reality of it is that BPM right now _IS_ The Beat. It's the same recurrents, same out of place selections (new wave, Bananarama, Aretha Franklin(!!)), reliance on remixes (waiting for them to bring back "Remixes on the Sixes") and lack of liners. I'm sorry, but if Sirius wanted my opinion on another channel to bring back- I have a few I'd like to see, but The Beat is VERY last on that list. I would, however, support bringing some of the recurrents from The Beat over to Strobe (esp the new wave or Bananarama or Madonna's).
I would think that it would be ideal for us to have a unified goal in the message we try to send Sirius' higher ups. We should think of ourselves as triage nurses, though. Let's face it, BPM (and the rest of the dance offerings on Sirius XM) is (are) [a] very sick patient(s). Just as the triage nurse who doesn't bring every patient in the e.r. in at once, we need to focus on one or two core suggestions. Right now, it's fix BPM by removing anything that isn't a reflection of the current (that's April 26,2009) top airplay charts for Dance (that's Dance, and not alternative nor pop). That is what I expect from a channel billing itself as Sirius' home for Dance HITS. Once that is accomplished, I'm with you on trying to bring back another channel or modifying Strobe's product mix.
You've got quite a voice and a way for mobilizing people, Tony. All I hope for is that you consider these thoughts.