@Fenris: I had several of the older version of the DN-C635 players (the exact model escapes me at the moment) and they actually held up well. I don't know the exact nature of the failure(s) you had but I'm not surprised if it's a heavily used studio.
Just because the word "professional" is silk screened on the front doesn't mean it's so. In recent months I acquired several Denon DN-C620's and Tascam CDU-01 Pro players. It stymies me why the hell anybody would develop a slot-load player for STUDIO use! All the players had their disc loading roller covered with dust and debris, making it impossible to eject the disc. Once that was clean 80% of the players worked with one Tascam having a bad transport sensor. I'm not surprised the station that owned these pitched them.
JBoyd has it right on the money - buy inexpensive CD players and consider them disposable. The AM oldies outlet I engineered had Technics SL-P1200 players that became more of a nightmare than anybody would have imagined. The eventually got swapped in the air studio for $100 Technics home units with externally added push buttons with the AutoCue function that was hidden on the front panel PC board. I wired in a remote start to the console via a DIN plug and it worked like a charm.
For those still using CD players it comes down to do you want to be married to a high-end player and be committed to servicing it (i.e., bearings, lasers, re-alignment, etc.) or just buying a small truckload of cheapo players and tossing them when they crap out.