>>>Maybe some country stations might want to try an all-country Christmas format where they play only Christmas songs from country artists past and present.<<<
Well, let's remember that in the days just before Christmas, most Country stations play both Country and standard Christmas songs mixed with their regular Country playlists. You hear an occasional Bing Crosby, Nat King Cole, Carpenters and Andy Williams holiday song, especially Dec. 24th and 25th. So I doubt any Country station that wanted to go all-Christmas would limit itself to only Country artists.
I've always wondered why everyone uses virtually the same Christmas playlist, whether the other 10 months of the year they are AC, Hot AC, Classic Hits or some other format. Hot AC stations don't eliminate the Burl Ives and Dean Martin songs in favor of Mariah Carey and N Sync. Classic Hits stations don't play more Beach Boys, Motown and Elvis Christmas songs than other Christmas stations. And as I said above, KKGO Los Angeles doesn't play any extra Country artists in its Christmas playlist than would be heard on KOST.
But in a market where there are two or three Country stations, hey, one should give it a shot. Maybe 80% Country artists and 20% traditional artists, all doing Christmas songs, when the AC station in town has gone with its usual Christmas playlist. Maybe that would combat Country ratings erosion in December and Holiday ratings?