Steven Roy said:
henry said:
But I'd much rather have Conway break the technical aspects of "good announcing" and keep churning out crazy opinions, than vice-verse. Most talent between the 118 freeway and the 10 are genuinely nuts. It takes a lot of coaching, agents, and re-takes to make them look "normal" on the TV and silver screen. I'd say Handel, Kobylt, and Conway are all completely nuts. But that's what makes their shows funny. <
>It can be hard for middle and older demos to accept evolutionary change. (Remember the outrage when all the AM Music of Your Life stations flipped to sports ten years ago?) My former colleague I mention above (example #1) hates the "shaky, sloppy" camera work on "The Office." Yet, it was among NBC's most popular shows. It's change. It's how you win younger audiences --- which KFI desperately needs.
IMO, radio must be entertaining to attract listeners. Who cares if it's technically perfect? I once apologized on-air for the occasional stutter. A listener called in to say they loved me because I'm REAL, not some pre-programmed, monotone robot...like your example #1.
I can see what you're saying, but one can be entertaining without sounding like a stooge. I personally have a hard time following Jr a lot of the time, but it has more to do with the nature of his storytelling more than anything else. Yes, radio is different now. A highly rated top forty station in 1975 would most likely have a relatively smooth personalty with a nice voice, preferably mid-range to on the deep side. Now a top forty has a fast talking guy who rambles at times and has a lightweight voice, a LOT like Seacrest, and they sound interchangeable, almost hard to tell apart . Talk hosts today rarely sound like say Michael Jackson, though many do sound like they have their act together(See Bill Carroll). Then there's a guy with an act like Jr who really sounds like he wasn't even sure what he would talk about until about 2 minutes to air time. He rarely knows of what he speaks, and that can be annoying at times. I don't think one needs to be technically perfect, but it could help to sound like you know how to walk & chew gum at the same time.
Steven Roy, you're assuming that von nupkins is of a certain age because of his gripes, but I would submit that it's not age but education and intelligence that motivates his postings about Jr and less or even not at all about how old he is. There have always been exceptions to what was considered the "norm" throughout history. Not everyone sounded like Charlie Tuna back in the 70's(See Ken Levine) and Conway is unique, as well as outside of the "norm". But being unique only goes so far, it helps to have your act together and to know what you're talking about once in a while. Jr is all about his opinion, and while nice, opinion can't carry the whole show, you have to show a little knowledge once in a while too. As for change, I don't recall ANY outrage when the Music of Your Life stations starting falling off the grid. But then again, I'm not nor will I ever be THAT audience, so I wasn't exposed to any perceived outrage. Formats are eventually updated or they go away and when they do, people move on as well, or they buy an ipod and load it up with what they really want to hear. Oh, and being a "classic" broadcaster can mean many things. I agree that your #2 example can be entertaining, but many don't last long because they don't try to understand their business and to learn how to make their act grow and evolve. Ad for example #1, I know "classic" broadcasters who fit the uptight mold you described, I also know "classic" broadcasters that are as cool as they come. To borrow an old line, they were and still are "hip", up on everything that any 25 year old is. They just happen to have a broadcasting education. And on the topic of having an FCC license, it's too bad they abolished that system. I've seen many people come into a station without knowing diddly-squat about how to maintain a program log or know any of the basics in order to
not get their station fined by the feds. They know NOTHING about their own business and it shows. And that's just sad, especially at the major market level...