I think Mike is doing better in the afternoons. Dave and Jimmy have to be dropped, but the solution is a tough one.
I would try to syndicate the real Morning Mess (Jason, Kelly, and Gavin) out of Cali. They can still have Bob and Chris doing the local news and traffic.
Either that or look for talent outside of the radio broadcasting circle. KISS FM is a station that does it all wrong. They need to have a week of "try-outs" where they allow regular 20-somethings with no broadcasting experience an opportunity to take the gig. It would increase ratings, build website traffic for voting, and reconnect with the younger local listeners.
If Bob Hauer wasn't busy doing the news for multiple stations, I would have him do mornings. He's fun and into sports.
So there you have it. Three possibilities for KISS FM. I personally think that the syndicated Morning Mess show would be a success. That's if their PD still allows their creative juices to flow.
For option #2, CC would have to step up and offer something the other stations don't. They would have to open up the lines for requests in the morning. Also, have some sort of poll or a short "issues" segment. But the "try-out" idea is, in my opinion, brilliant. Of course you wouldn't have just anyone on there. But I think they could find at least 5 people who are really passionate about radio, have no experience, and would appreciate the opportunity.
For option #3, I'm not sure who would pair well with Bob. Surely they could find someone in sales department with some on-air talent that isn't doing anything.