• Get involved.
    We want your input!
    Apply for Membership and join the conversations about everything related to broadcasting.

    After we receive your registration, a moderator will review it. After your registration is approved, you will be permitted to post.
    If you use a disposable or false email address, your registration will be rejected.

    After your membership is approved, please take a minute to tell us a little bit about yourself.
    https://www.radiodiscussions.com/forums/introduce-yourself.1088/

    Thanks in advance and have fun!
    RadioDiscussions Administrators

DIRECTV vs. DISH

I've been a DirecTV customer now for about three-and-a-half years in standard definition.

I'm planning on getting into the 21st century and getting an HD set. I've noticed that Dish has way more and diverse program offerings than Direct, and it has Turner Classic Movies, a favorite channel in HD. Directv does not. Dish seems to have way more movie channels in HD as well.

What is everybody's general reaction/experience with Dish, and/or Dish vs. Direct.

Thanks....
 
HD aside, I personally don't like DISH NETWORK because they DO NOT carry The YES NETWORK. Where I used to live the landlord had DISH NETWORK. I had to go an entire baseball season without my Yankees on TV aside from the 20 or so games shown locally on MY TV 9 or nationally on FOX.

DISH also seemed to go out more during extremely heavy rain. When I had DISH my parents who lived 15 mins away had Directv and often times I would tell them DISH went out while my they said Directv is fine.
 
I've known people who have DISH and the overall program offerings, such as the mix channels, sports packages and overall HD offerings, on DirecTV put it to shame.
 
Why would you bother paying for HD to watch Turner Classic Movies?

That said, if you are going to watch mostly movies in HD I would buy an upscaling or Blu-Ray DVD player to get the best possible picture. Watching HD over highly compressed satellite is only marginally better than SD. You can rent a bunch of DVD's for the cost of satellite.

Live sports (not aired over OTA) in HD would be the only reason I would get sat HD.

As far as the companies go....read very carefully your subscription contract. Both companies use every trick in the book to stick it to you. Personally, I will never do business with DISH again because of their business practices. I've had both services and found them to be technically acceptable. But if I'm going to go 'for the HD gold' I'll wait until fiber comes to my neighborhood and go with cable.
 
DirecTV is adding HD channels all the time, and I have discovered that sometimes there are there even before they appear in your onscreen listings. (for example, a few weeks back they started carrying WGN America in HD. It is still not listed, and I found out only by stumbling across it with my channel up-down button).
 
schmave said:
I've known people who have DISH and the overall program offerings, such as the mix channels, sports packages and overall HD offerings, on DirecTV put it to shame.

I am one of those. Directv's programming, particularly their HD programming, beats Dish hands down. Before you make a decision either way, you should decide what programming package you want. Then print them out and compare them side by side. I personally, like Directv's service.
 
Here's my breakdown:

For the most popular HD channels, it's a toss-up. If you enjoy movies and/or the audio-only music channels, go with Dish. If you're a big sports fan, you may lean towards DirecTV. As far as equipment, the Dish DVR is much more responsive than DirecTV's.

Your mileage may vary, though.
 
landtuna said:
Why would you bother paying for HD to watch Turner Classic Movies?

That said, if you are going to watch mostly movies in HD I would buy an upscaling or Blu-Ray DVD player to get the best possible picture. Watching HD over highly compressed satellite is only marginally better than SD. You can rent a bunch of DVD's for the cost of satellite.

Live sports (not aired over OTA) in HD would be the only reason I would get sat HD.

As far as the companies go....read very carefully your subscription contract. Both companies use every trick in the book to stick it to you. Personally, I will never do business with DISH again because of their business practices. I've had both services and found them to be technically acceptable. But if I'm going to go 'for the HD gold' I'll wait until fiber comes to my neighborhood and go with cable.

When I've watched Turner Classic Movies at Best Buy it looks terrible on the Samsung LED 46" set I've been seriously looking at (and the rest of the 480i channels as well). I'm not looking at the movies being in high resolution (that takes remastering of the original film negatives), but at least it is going to not be as pixelated since it is being delivered at a higher resolution.

I'll consider the other options though you mentioned. I noticed on a side-by-side comparison that Dish Network has a lot more of the public interest channels I'm interested in, University of California, etc., etc.
 
sdwulfdawg said:
When I've watched Turner Classic Movies at Best Buy it looks terrible on the Samsung LED 46" set I've been seriously looking at (and the rest of the 480i channels as well).

That apparently is a common problem with HDTV. In reading various reviews of HDTV's there are some that don't have the SD problem. CNET seems to be a good source for reviews and goggling should provide even more. I don't have an HDTV so haven't experienced the problem first hand.
 
I've had a ton of providers for cable TV, DirecTV, Dish, Comcast, Time Warner, MediaOne and AT&T Broadband and let me tell you that out of all of them, two really stood out for me, Dish Network (which I currently have) and Comcast (which I would have kept if Comcast didn't sell their wirings in my area to Time Warner).

Dish Network is really straight to the point in getting you the best deals, unlike DirecTV they don't chunk together a million channels you won't watch and charge you crazy prices for them. They also have a huge selection of HD and are going to add more channels as we speak with the recent launch of their new satellite.

The CEO and president have a talk show every few months to keep the customers updated on what's going on at the company and even let people call in and ask questions. I like how they aren't afraid to get on the same level with their customers unlike other cable/satellite providers. Some complaints about Dish though are that their 2 TV receivers can be difficult at times, especially with the fact that if you lose the remote for TV 2, you can't change the channel until you get a replacement shipped from Dish. But customer service is great in shipping a new one out for free with you usually only playing for shipping.

Let me just comment, worse cable service I've ever had, AT&T Broadband. Just absolutely HORRIBLE! I'm sure their new U-Verse service is different but AT&T Broadband was the definition of the stereotypical cable company
 
I've never had Direct TV but I have had Dish Network and I have to say it wasn't very good. We were always dropping the local channels every time the wind blew it seemed. They also get you for 18 months unless you want to pay a fee to leave. So it was pretty much 18 months of hell with the locals dropping signal every day. I think about 2 months after our contract ended one of our receives stopped working and when we called them they said that we would need to pay to have a new one shipped out. It was about $40 causing us to decide to cancel our service and switch back to cable. It will be 2 years this September when we dropped Dish and went back to MetroCast. Haven't lost signal once. Of course you could have better luck.
 
Thanks to Dish, we now get our locals in the Wheeling (WV) and Steubenville, Ohio DMA. Our previous cable provider pulled up stakes in late February, causing us to strongly consider erecting an antenna system and switching to DirecTV. After we learned we were getting locals, we dropped our order. One concern we DO have with Dish is the loss of signal during heavy rain.

My parents are in an area where cable was never an option. After the DTV conversion, they could no longer access locals. I'm assuming they will switch back to Dish after their DirecTV contract ends.

BTW. does anyone know if/when DirecTV will follow Dish's lead and provide signals for all markets?
 
My 2 cents about DirecTV.

I originally had then AT&T (Now Comcast) cable when I lived in Sunnyvale, but in August 2001, my parents originally got DirecTV and personally, I'm not too happy of the way that they do business, their signals kept dropping off, the contract for 2 years was almost $500 at the time, plus having all of those channels including their so called NFL Sunday ticket was just too much to handle and after the first year, the total bill was $750! Their response to technical issues were also bad too when it came to freezeouts with the DVR. There was no KFTY Channel 50 yet as DirecTV did not get KFTY until 2006-07. One flaw to point out about DirecTV here, I overheard that the DirecTV recievers were very easy to hack with the Access cards that were recieving illegal signals while Dish Network's recievers worked completely fine and was 100% hackproof making it very difficult to get illegal signals. Another thing was that DirecTV's cancellation service was so bad, that my parents had to file a claim due to dissatisfaction of services.

In December, 2003, my parents dropped DirecTV because of bad service and went with Dish Network. We have been customers ever since. For one thing even though all of the sports packages from DirecTV are so cool, the prices really jack up to a very big price in which it makes it very difficuly to afford, also the Distant Network Signals are limited to NYC and LA with CW service from Washington D.C. (WDCW) and San Diego (XETV) while I get the same stuff on Dish Network with the fact that I get stations besides my locals out of Monterey/Salinas I get the major 5 superstations (KTLA, KWGN, WSBK, WWOR, WPIX) and it really helps whenever I want to watch my Regis & Kelly out of KWGN at 8 AM since I do not want to wait that much for my other shows I watch (Let's Make a Deal & Price is Right). DirecTV sadly doesn't care about since they are only caring about Sports Packages and stuff plus WGN America being in HD since 2005 with Dish, plus KFTY was added to Dish in 2004. The Distant Networks are also good too since a 3rd party controls them after Dish could no longer import the signals themselves. I am about 65-70 miles away from my local signals so I could get stations from San Francisco (SD), LA and Chicago (HD) it's just a shame that DirecTV does not allow their Distant Networks to be in HD :( I really am very happy with my Dish because at least the pricing is affordable and I really like how Charlie Ergen does have his own show to discuss his concerns and how he can improve Dish Service and I like that when it comes to caring about their customers. Unfortunately, I feel that DirecTV is only after making their sports channels big and jacking up prices as well as overcharging their customers and I was very upset about that when I discontinued DirecTV in 2003, now they are completely b***hurt and are asking us to come back to them, one answer to them, NO!
 
Like another poster said if you like Movies Dish is the way to go.. Dish has Epix and IndiePlex and RetroPlex from Encore plus a host of other movie channels. For the sports person DirecTV would be your best bet... I have had Dish for 11 years and have been very happy with them for the most part... CC1
 
Greg Goodfellow said:
Thanks to Dish, we now get our locals in the Wheeling (WV) and Steubenville, Ohio DMA. Our previous cable provider pulled up stakes in late February, causing us to strongly consider erecting an antenna system and switching to DirecTV. After we learned we were getting locals, we dropped our order. One concern we DO have with Dish is the loss of signal during heavy rain.

My parents are in an area where cable was never an option. After the DTV conversion, they could no longer access locals. I'm assuming they will switch back to Dish after their DirecTV contract ends.

BTW. does anyone know if/when DirecTV will follow Dish's lead and provide signals for all markets?

That is impressive, since Steubenville/Wheeling is such a small market (and has a very uneven overlap with the much larger
Pittsburgh market). I have DirecTV, and my brother has Dish, and we both have the same issue with dropouts during heavy rain.
(that is an FCC allocation problem and not the carrier....they were assigned a wavelength that approximates the physical size of a raindrop!) I have noticed that the HD is the first to go, so in moderately heavy rain I can still watch programs in 480i.
 
I have had both, and Comcast(Xfinity), and of all 3 Comcast is the best they just added 50 more HD channels in my area Central Valley CA, I've Had my HD DVR for 2 years and never had problems, I've had to replace the Directv DVR about 4 times in a year and a half and The dish DVR also about 4 times in the 4 years I had them.I compared the HD channels with the new 50 to Dish and Directv and Comcast has more, they don't offer WGN America in HD though or TV LAND. I don't think TV LAND in HD is even available for anybody.
Dish would go out in heavy rain storm, not so much with Directv, Comcast here may have gone out once or twice in the 2 years i've had them.
Comcast has most of the Local Sub channels like RTV and THIS-TV, satellite has none of them.
 
kenrayc said:
Dish would go out in heavy rain storm, not so much with Directv, Comcast here may have gone out once or twice in the 2 years i've had them.
Comcast has most of the Local Sub channels like RTV and THIS-TV, satellite has none of them.

Heavy rain is a major concern in San Diego ;D ::) :p
 
sdwulfdawg said:
kenrayc said:
Dish would go out in heavy rain storm, not so much with Directv, Comcast here may have gone out once or twice in the 2 years i've had them.
Comcast has most of the Local Sub channels like RTV and THIS-TV, satellite has none of them.

Heavy rain is a major concern in San Diego ;D ::) :p


Yea I'm about 340 miles North, we only get an average of 12" of rain here in Clovis (San Joaquin valley is like a desert, especially in the summer).Even though, seems like Dish went out more that Directv in the rain.
 
Status
This thread has been closed due to inactivity. You can create a new thread to discuss this topic.


Back
Top Bottom