I thought Doug McIntyre's last national show was good. He repeatedly noted that he wanted to remain with Red Eye for the rest of his life. I believed him. He worked the show like a comfy old show and made Red Eye personal to the listeners. One must conclude that the baseball like "trade for the good of the team" that he repeated said took place moving him not by choice from a national perch to a local station not doing too well, was perhaps less than fully candid. McIntyre is well suited for Red Eye and for late or overnight radio. He has the personality for it and, based on the callers whose bond with Doug appears quite real and sincere, many listeners will feel his loss across the country. How he (and his music) will attempt to fit into KABC's morning drive will an interesting challenge. As well, while another poster correctly stated that Doug's Red Eye show appeared to be lacking in advertisers and maybe wasn't a profit center, will his new show make money and ratings for bedraggled KABC?
KABC was for many, many years the standard against which other talk stations were measured. KABC was great and held court at or near the top of the tier for decades. For years, KLAC, KGIL, KIEV, and more so KFI, worked to hold a candle to the live, local, consistent excellence that was KABC. Now not even a shadow of its former self, one wonders how and why the long fall from grace came about and what might be done to reverse it. Doug and Elmer for morning drive might help at the margins. But they need a big break-out in live, local programs (you know, talk shows that are interesting and that take calls - what a concept of talk programming: taking calls!).
Lastly, for years I wondered why departing talkers and hosts are generally not given a last show (see Ladd, KLOS) to thank loyal listeners and staff. Listening to Tilden over the last week or two provided the answer. No last shows or weeks to simply make a bad or toxic situation worse.
A simply awful show for a long, long time well before news of the programming change, Tilden has achieved what I thought was something simply impossible: His KABC show is now worse than ever. The man who promised on his very first day back at KABC mornings to work harder than ever, to be the best prepared, etc., simply drifted downward over the last two years to find and envelope all that is true mediocrity. Now, as he is soon to leave mornings (and the station??), his morning show is nothing less than an embarrassment to KABC, to the history and integrity of KABC (which, again, factually was a shining beacon of a station), KABC's dwindling listenership (can it be recovered??), and to himself.
So no more, please. Shut Tilden's microphone now -- right now -- before the new morning team starts Jan 3rd. The long good-bye, and Tilden's on-air complaints (down to the ages-old chair he suffers loudly and the always dirty mic he finds on Monday mornings after the weekend infomercial guys have slobbered over it, and, hmmm, his shall I say "exaggerations" that are getting worse and easier to disprove) combine to make what was an already sloppy show painfully hard to listen to as it nears its end; his limited credibility long-since over.
Shutting Tilden down now, if nothing else, may provide McIntyre as much of a clean slate as is possible to begin the long task of KABC's attempted rebuild. P.S.: A morning drive talk show CAN take listener calls and do news, traffic, stock reports, and place many paid commercials. Not a secret recipe. Can be done and was done successfully for years here in Los Angeles and elsewhere.
KABC can work. It can rise again. Live, local, tight, consistent (but with variety and no talk shows reairs) news/talk programs that take calls, that talk to political and other newsmakers on an up-to-the-minute basis, kicking up the sorely lacking news standards and product, and, to be sure, the selling or re-selling of KABC to audience and natl/local advertisers will take time, money, great people and a great team -- it can be done. This old talk radio producer and occasional on-air guy from KLAC, others, won't be holding his breath but will be hoping for the best for Talkradio 790 KABC.