Allow me to join the discussion or butt-in, depending on your perspective. As the midday guy on a
radio station that transitioned from Oldies to Classic Hits to Gold based AC over the last three years, I can appreciate the points of view in this thread.
The "problem" with Oldies isn't the format in and of itself, it's the presentation. If a station is doing the bells, gongs and whistles routine and living in the past, it's destined to bleed out. If the station has a contemporary, "living in the now" presentation, it can succeed.
Like listeners, so many of us tend to stereotype Oldies. Is it The Big Bopper, Girl Groups and The Everly Brothers? Maybe Beatles and Motown? Is it British Invasion and the 70's? Is it the 70's and 80's? Is it a careful "mix" (subtle inference) of all these genres?
Personally, I'm not fond of the word "Oldies" as a format description. I know the word translates well with listeners, a soft blanket that covers all categories, but I prefer "Classic Hits" as a format description.
I've been a PD of a fairly succesful Classic Hits station (ironically, on the frequency I'm working at now) and jocked on an enormously successful Oldies station (also the same frequency.) There's a distinction in presentation, rotations and attitude. I've also jocked Classic Rock, Country and AC. Classic Hits incorporates a more contemporary approach, attitudinally, musically and in jock presentation. From where I am in my life (over 49,) it's my favorite format to work.
Classic Hits can't help but incorporate
format compatible music from the 80's and maybe even the early 90's. And why not! It is, afterall, 2008! Some U2 hits are 22 years old... The Clash's "Rock the Casbah," (or, "robbin' the cashbox" according to dyslexic lyrics fans) reeks of 60's Kinks-Yardbirds influence is also 25 years old. They're Classics. Arguably, they're Oldies.... for a new generation.
The difficulty in getting Elvis to work with U2, and the Supremes to work with Bonnie Raitt and all these great songs to work together lies in properly constructing the music rotations, positioning the station on a promotional level and shaping the jock presentations. Not easy, but that's where a good program director and a great airstaff come into play.