• Get involved.
    We want your input!
    Apply for Membership and join the conversations about everything related to broadcasting.

    After we receive your registration, a moderator will review it. After your registration is approved, you will be permitted to post.
    If you use a disposable or false email address, your registration will be rejected.

    After your membership is approved, please take a minute to tell us a little bit about yourself.
    https://www.radiodiscussions.com/forums/introduce-yourself.1088/

    Thanks in advance and have fun!
    RadioDiscussions Administrators

FCC Approves All-Digital Option for AM

The digital migration of AM and FM is to streaming. Momentum on HD receivers has gone in the wrong direction for the last 5 or more years. After the initial push, the HD car and home adapters, HD home receivers have been discontinued and from what I can tell aftermarket car radios have largely dropped it. Even OEM car radios do not come standard with it so many/maybe most new cars still come without it.

Stations promote using Alexa or other digital assistants to listen at home and promote their phone apps. HD promotion is nil. Many/maybe most of the AM's that ran hybrid digital have dropped it. On FM the sound improvement on the main channel is negligible and for the HD 2,3,4 the programming is an after thought so very few people are seeking it out.

I thought it was an interesting technology when it came out and bought adapters for my cars, a home adapter and even a Yamaha surround sound receiver with it built in. Mostly for picking up the AM's in my area doing HD. But we've gone from 4 AM HD to 0 so I just pulled the last adapter out of my car.

We have more AM Stereo C-Quam stations (1) around here then we have HD AM (0) and the former was deemed a failure years ago.

I agree with everything you’ve stated. I personally have 2 HD Radios the Insignia table top and the Sangean HDR 16. The programming offerings in Detroit for the sub-channels are a tune out factor. What a total waste of money for me to purchase these radios just the Sangean alone cost me $195.00 after shipping and the Insignia $50.00 with that money I could’ve treated my wife and I to a good dinner and a great night out.
 
What a total waste of money for me to purchase these radios just the Sangean alone cost me $195.00 after shipping and the Insignia $50.00 with that money I could’ve treated my wife and I to a good dinner and a great night out.

But come on admit it, you're a radio nerd. If a radio with new features comes on the market, you must buy one.
 
But come on admit it, you're a radio nerd. If a radio with new features comes on the market, you must buy one.

That depends, if a $250 night out with the wife includes getting lucky than I can skip the new radio.
 
If you need to hope to "get lucky" on a night out with your WIFE, you probably have been spending too much time listening to your radios.

Or another way to look at it: If he hadn't spent money on new radios, he's stand a chance at getting lucky? Seems to me if that's a defining factor, they may want to consider counseling.
 
Too little too late. Would have been a great idea in 2000. But they decided to go with IBOC.

Now too many consumers already own digital audio devices called phones. They don't pick up AM.

But what's the difference between IBOC and all-digital on a practical level? Not much. Still need a digital AM radio to pick up IBOC digital.

I agree that kicking it off better in 2000 would have been preferable. The problem for radio listeners was the dearth of HD radios, and those few that were available were expensive.

Not the best way to kick off a new technology.
 
Here’s another problem with programming. Here in Detroit the HD2 and HD3 stations that play Oldies repeat songs in some cases within 6 hours. And it seems that here in Detroit the IHeart stations have eliminated half of their HD2 & 3 stations. We used to have a Classic Funk, Classic Soul and a Classic Rock format on HD2 and HD3 stations now they’re gone and apparently the big broadcasters don’t care about HD Radio on FM and are they willing to go all digital on AM radio? I don’t see any AM here in Detroit going all digital ever.

I've noticed a relative clearing of HD on FM here in Seattle as well. Not sure if it's cost, equipment breakdown, corona, or whatever. Even the HD-1 (the main HD channel) on a couple big local stations is gone.
 
But what's the difference between IBOC and all-digital on a practical level? Not much. Still need a digital AM radio to pick up IBOC digital.

I agree that kicking it off better in 2000 would have been preferable. The problem for radio listeners was the dearth of HD radios, and those few that were available were expensive.

Not the best way to kick off a new technology.
The difference is that there are millions of radios capable of picking it up! It isn't hundreds of millions but it's something.
 
But what's the difference between IBOC and all-digital on a practical level? Not much. Still need a digital AM radio to pick up IBOC digital.

I agree that kicking it off better in 2000 would have been preferable. The problem for radio listeners was the dearth of HD radios, and those few that were available were expensive.

Not the best way to kick off a new technology.

There is nothing new being kicked-off. When AT&T, later Ibquity introduced the digital platform for AM, the intent was always to leave open the option for digital-only use. That's why any HD Radio receiver from the first models introduced can receive IBOC, or MA3 full-digital mode. The only thing new, is the Commission finally allowing AM operators to choose whether to run MA3.
 
HD (Huge Disappointment) Radio will continue to die a slow death both on AM and FM. A technology consumers never asked for. The true digital radio platform remains through our smartphones via an app or website. Regular radio will remain a good source for cheap (free) entertainment and information for decades to come. If it’s not broke, don’t fix it.
 
Regular radio will remain a good source for cheap (free) entertainment and information for decades to come. If it’s not broke, don’t fix it.

AM radio may not be broken, but it's rapidly dying of old age. You're either in denial, or one of those who willfully choose to ignore reality..
 
AM radio may not be broken, but it's rapidly dying of old age. You're either in denial, or one of those who willfully choose to ignore reality..
Until they change the law that requires payment for every listener, streaming is going to need an assist from a broadcast signal. I don't see that changing anytime soon.
 
HD (Huge Disappointment) Radio will continue to die a slow death both on AM and FM. A technology consumers never asked for. The true digital radio platform remains through our smartphones via an app or website. Regular radio will remain a good source for cheap (free) entertainment and information for decades to come. If it’s not broke, don’t fix it.

Consumers didn't ask for a lot of technologies. I don't recall consumers screaming for computers that would give us TV and social media, as well as spam. I recall BBS's being mostly the domain of computer geeks during the late 80's and even the early 1990's. That was only 25 years or so ago -- which was when the WWW became a mainstay for people.

I don't think consumers were screaming for FM. It didn't take off until the late 1970's really, and it was on many radios for at least 30 years before then.

A lot of technologies had been around for a while and then took off, once enough people saw the benefit.

HD was not marketed to the consumer well, and the manufacturers were not really on board until a few years ago, when reasonably priced radios were available, but by then the ship mostly had sailed. I include HD FM as well. I love listening to some of the FM HD2 channels, but I think they won't be around too long, especially if they acquire the scrutiny of digital royalty people.
 
Consumers didn't ask for a lot of technologies. I don't recall consumers screaming for computers that would give us TV and social media, as well as spam. I recall BBS's being mostly the domain of computer geeks during the late 80's and even the early 1990's. That was only 25 years or so ago -- which was when the WWW became a mainstay for people.

I don't think consumers were screaming for FM. It didn't take off until the late 1970's really, and it was on many radios for at least 30 years before then.

A lot of technologies had been around for a while and then took off, once enough people saw the benefit.

HD was not marketed to the consumer well, and the manufacturers were not really on board until a few years ago, when reasonably priced radios were available, but by then the ship mostly had sailed. I include HD FM as well. I love listening to some of the FM HD2 channels, but I think they won't be around too long, especially if they acquire the scrutiny of digital royalty people.

You are off on the dates, but your point about many technologies not being "asked for" by consumers is valid.

Things like the cotton gin were asked for as planters looked for better ways to harvest. Cars were not asked for, although some inventors tried to convert the steam rail engine to an un-railed vehicle. The care was initially the subject of much negative criticism.

We did not know we needed radio. In fact, until the Titanic disaster caused legislators to require radio on ships, there was skepticism.

So innovation is sometimes caused by need and sometimes by developer "what if" curiosity.

As to timing, FM was growing in the mid-60's and the non-duplication rules from the FCC made it really begin to prosper in the late 60's. As a personal note, I had a high rated and very successful, profitable FM in 1966. By the mid-70's more than half of all listening was on FM. However, it was not until the early 70's that receivers started to have FM in their majorities. The reasons why FM did not succeed earlier have to do with issues like the Armstrong patents, lack of an AFC system and high cost.

Dial-up services like Compuserve´and Prodigy go back to the early 70's. I subscribed and used CIS daily from Puerto Rico in 1975. There were many dial-in BBS services, but the long distance charges from my location were prohibitive... but they existed in the 70's

The evolution of computers was very slow at the personal (PC) level. My first one in '75 used an OS on paper tape and had no permanent memory in the system; every start-up was a total reload. The average person had no use for one, and those of us who had one used them as learning and experimental devices. It would be several years before, still in the 70's, I could use PCs for our in-house research... and for budgets and, shortly after, music logs.

As technology developed, people found things that could be more efficiently and better done with computers. Just as cars developed with the limitations of a lack of paved roads and other infrastructure like gas stations.
 
Last edited:
Instead of trying to clear out the band, they are trying to resuscitate about 3,000 cadavers.

In some ways, the band will be cleared out since the digital hash could be confused with noise.

Jeff in Sa-ra-so-ta!
 
HD (Huge Disappointment) Radio will continue to die a slow death both on AM and FM. A technology consumers never asked for. The true digital radio platform remains through our smartphones via an app or website. Regular radio will remain a good source for cheap (free) entertainment and information for decades to come. If it’s not broke, don’t fix it.

Au contraire. HD radio is at its strongest now due to the FCC permitting translators to be allowed to simulcast HD-2 and beyond channels, effectively creating additional viable FM stations. Additionally, in many markets the HD channel has become an accessible and viable service for foreign language and religious broadcasters.
 
Au contraire. HD radio is at its strongest now due to the FCC permitting translators to be allowed to simulcast HD-2 and beyond channels, effectively creating additional viable FM stations. Additionally, in many markets the HD channel has become an accessible and viable service for foreign language and religious broadcasters.

I can see the lines forming as we speak at my local Best Buy with HD Radio customers. Just wondering how many Insignia HD Radios will be sold on Black Friday or should I say how many are on the shelf. Damn and I just donated two HD Radios to Salvation Army yesterday, my bad. But truly I get what you’re saying, it’s great for some broadcasters but on the consumer level no one cares about HD Radio most will stream their radio instead.
 
Status
This thread has been closed due to inactivity. You can create a new thread to discuss this topic.


Back
Top Bottom