Here in Poughkeepsie, NY, 88.3 is also kind of a mess, with many stations fairly close.
Dominant is WFSO Olivebridge, NY, Traditional Religious "Redeemer Broadcasting" at 21 miles.
Also regular is W202AR, comtemporary Christian translator for "Sound of Life" at 25 miles.
There was a CP for another translator on 88.3 with 3 watts about 15 miles from me, but that has aparently expired.
DX on 88.3
KABF Little Rock, AR most distant on 88.3 at 1115 miles
KBPN Brainerd, MN Minnesota Public Radio (1097 miles)
WBGO Newark, NJ Jazz often heard, sometimes in HD. (73 miles)
WVCR Loudonville, NY "The Saint" (60 miles)
WLIU Southampton, NY (96 miles)
WLKA Tafton PA "K-Love". (81 miles)