SoulCrusher said:
I think the sound of Fresh is closer to Blink's second incarnation, which was given at least one or two books before it was deemed a failure. At first Blink had a sound that was close to PLJ, but then it shifted to become Lite FM for the younger demos. So now they're trying it again under a different name, but one important thing has changed - Lite FM is not sounding quite as dated and stodgy as it has in years past, despite CBS's attempt to paint the competition as such. And judging by the ratings the station has pulled, it appears to me that the general consensus would concur with that point of view - the station would not be doing well with Females below 40 if they were still playing "You Light Up My Life" and songs of that ilk. CBS has made a lot of foolish programming decisions in NYC in recent years, and I would definitely consider Fresh to be another one to add to the list. Aren't there enough stations out there that lean toward Female tastes, including their own Jack-FM? Instead of trying something that previously failed, why not try Active or Alternative Rock, Classic Hip-Hop, or even Country? Oh yeah - these are the geniuses that favored blowing up the market's only Oldies and Modern Rock stations. We can't expect them to make any rational decisions, you know.
I will not get into the country music in NYC debate again, I will not get into the country music in NYC debate again....
In all seriousness, Blink II got less than a book. The Christmas music format started sometime in November of 2003 but the AC stuff started sometime in September. At most it was approximately two months with practically zero promotion. It wasn't given a chance, *and* it was still named after a station, Blink, which completely failed in the ratings.
As far as Lite FM, it doesn't matter whether or not Fresh's ads about Lite's music is accurate. Fresh is trying to create an impression of Lite FM as an older, sleepier station--whether or not that actually is true doesn't matter. It's playing on perceptions rather than reality, but that's advertising. So far, it does seem that Fresh is at least being sampled by a lot of new listeners, including Lite listeners. That does mean that in some way, the marketing is working. Whether or not Fresh will keep them hooked, time will tell.
Oldies has been blown up in most major markets, and now we're beginning to see the same with classical music, another older-skewing format. I can't really blame them for doing that, the reality is that the numbers for CBS-FM were going down. One thing I did not agree with is the return of the FM talk format with Free FM. It failed once before and so far, it's failing again, despite what everyone says. I know that talk formats typically need time to develop, but come on....they've promoted the s**t out of the station and have some well-known people who have been on the air before and are familiar to the NYC audience, and they still cannot even beat WADO in the ratings. Part of the problem though is that K-Rock was not modern rock before it was killed off...the music had been tweaked to a weird classic/active rock hybrid, for lack of a better term. I still feel that a hip, well-programmed rock station targeting the younger demos would do respectably well, and the young male demo is more underserved than young women.
Classic hip-hop is not a bad idea, but the urban demo already is very crowded, much more so than AC. Unfortunately I can see that format going the way of Jammin' Oldies, however, if ever attemped.
Country just won't happen in NYC. It's been talked about to death on this and other boards.